4 ms·
What if the publisher-subsidized service offers free access to everything at some baseline slow rate – say 128kbps – and then partner sites at a higher rate? Th
by gojomo 16y ago
What if the publisher-subsidized service offers free access to everything at some baseline slow rate – say 128kbps – and then partner sites at a higher rate? That could bring 90s-level internet access to everyone. If lack of affordable net access is a real problem, shouldn't this company and its potential customers be allowed to try this mechanism?
- kragen 16y agoI think I've shown above that lack of affordable net access is not a real problem in the US — it's apparently already more widespread than adequate housing, adequate nutrition, and adequate health care — but BoxTop, if successful, could make it a real problem. So, should they be allowed to try this mechanism? That's the whole net neutrality debate. The net-neutrality position says, "No," or in its milder form, "They should be allowed to sell crippled TCP/IP services but not advertise them as internet access." You're probably familiar with the arguments for net neutrality already, so I won't repeat them again.
- kragen 16y agoEven though this lowers my average comment score, I think it's worthwhile linking to this just-issued FCC report, "Internet Access Services: Status as of December 31, 2009": http://www.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2010/db1208/DOC-303405A1.pdf http://www.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2010/db1208... It seems to contradict the BoxTop statistic of 90.5%; it shows only 60 residential fixed connections per 100 households faster than 200kbps in at least one direction in 2009 (p.11). I find it deeply disturbing that in 87 pages of statistics about access speeds, there is not one single mention of whether these connections include publicly-routable IPv4 addresses, static IP addresses, or IPv6. (Unless I missed something?)