5 ms·
What Happened to Hovertrains? (2018) [video]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scythe 8y agoIt seems to me the fundamental inescapable problem with hovertrains was simple: they’re loud. Sound is a pressure wave, hovercraft require high pressures; therefore, they are noisy. Even if you solved momentum drag, track maintenance, and everything else, nobody will let you build it near their house. (Maybe a maglev train could hover only at low speeds inside a station. Maglev works better for moving trains rather than stationary ones. But then it’s not a hovertrain.)
- jessriedel 8y agoIt's not at all obvious to me that the noise from the pressure levitation system of a hovertrain is louder than the noise from drag, which the hovertrain and maglev both share. Do you have a link?
- klingonopera 8y agoTBH, I would've expected a Maglev train to "touch down" in a station, at least that is what I would do if I were to have designed it... Anyone here ever rode on the Maglev in China can provide more details?
- detaro 8y agoThey can touch down/"take off" while stationary (not sure if they do it while stopping in stations), but don't have wheels, so they have to hover to move at all. If both sides of the maglev system fail, they have skids designed to slow them at a safe rate, but that's emergency use only.
- russdill 8y agoJust an engineering aside, you'd probably want braces to engage the train rather than the train to lower. If it lowers you have to raise it before it starts again which would require extra energy and substantial force.
- klingonopera 8y agoI think a kind of "landing gear" would be preferable, as its operation could be station-independent, which in turn centralizes maintenance, therefore reducing running costs. AFAIK, there currently isn't an actual Maglev network in operation (just point-to-point - no traffic, no stops), but if there would be, I think it's easier to have any train be able to stop anywhere on the track than to have it stop at specific locations only. But other than that, yes, you're definitely right that any change of elevation of the entire train should be avoided as much as possible. EDIT: I just realized, my last paragraph isn't necessarily true either, i.e. compare the situation to start-stop-sytems on cars, there's a sweet spot in efficiency, when turning off the engine and starting it would cost more than letting it run all the time.
- rangibaby 8y agoJapan Rail’s solution to the noise problem was to bore a tunnel hundreds of kilometers from Tokyo to Osaka via Nagoya
- scythe 8y agoLooking at the Chuo Shinkansen, it seems that the tunnel allowed the train to turn less through the mountains, considering that turning is pretty hard to do at 500 kph! Also: >JR Central aims to begin commercial service between Tokyo and Nagoya in 2027, with the Nagoya–Osaka section originally planned to be completed by 2045.[5] The government is however planning to support a speed up of the timeline for the construction of the Osaka section by up to 8 years to 2037 with additional funds.[6] Imagine a US government construction project being finished ahead of schedule.
- melling 8y ago@1:10 Trains in Japan were initially only running at speeds up to 130 mph in 1964. Over half a century ago the world had bullet trains. I guess when we had 200 million Americans we didn’t think it was worth the effort. Now with an extra 130 million people, it’s too difficult and expensive.
- autokad 8y agoit will be more interesting if we ever get down the costs of energy, then we can focus on really fast tech. its also worth noting that trains between philadelphia and nyc (Acela Express) go ~135-165 mph. if it takes 6 hours and ~ 450$ to get from nyc to sf, it would be more revolutionary to reduce the cost by 50% than than cut the time in half I think.
- dmix 8y agoWhy are train tickets so expensive? I get long distances but it always seemed so expensive to me. For example I could go between Toronto-MTL by bus for $20-30 but by train its $100-120.
- nkoren 8y agoMany reasons, but for a start, the roads are much more subsidized than the rails are.
- snowwindwaves 8y agoFreight pays better than passengers. They don't want passengers. They might be obligated to maintain passenger service.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoIt's a good question, but having seen bus upkeep compared to train upkeep, it seems like it takes a lot more labor to keep a train moving. Might have something to do with how expensive replacement parts are. Bus engines are of course highly commoditized, where as a lot of trainsets are one-off manufactures, maybe replacement parts have to be special ordered? Just speculating.
- chungleong 8y agoOne thing I've been wondering is whether is possible to power a ground effect vehicle from overhead wires. That would sort of be like a hover train. The "tracks" would be cheap to build. Just need to compact the ground to a smooth surface.
- mpoteat 8y agoSan Francisco has this. Buses are powered by overhead wires. (because electrified tracks would kill pedestrians)
- _tulpa 8y agoLots of places have that, definitely almost nobody has ground-effect vehicles (which would satisfy the 'hover' bit): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-effect_vehicle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground-effect_vehicle
- fulafel 8y agoThe need to constantly produce lift would probably consume a lot of energy.
- dzhiurgis 8y agoI think solar energy is enough, at least for small prototypes.
- chungleong 8y agoLift-induced drag goes down with the square of velocity. At high speed, the need to stay aloft doesn't cost you that much.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoThey will build (my perception) a hyperloop/maglev train between St. Louis and Kansas City. https://www.stlmag.com/news/missouri-could-be-getting-a-hyperloop-from-st-louis-to-kansa/ https://www.stlmag.com/news/missouri-could-be-getting-a-hype...