3 ms·
I think the point that the author makes it sensible, but I think the defence of free will itself isn't really addressed. What I agree with is that intentionali
by Barrin92 8y ago
I think the point that the author makes it sensible, but I think the defence of free will itself isn't really addressed.
What I agree with is that intentionality and free will are useful concepts to describe how agents behave. There is no need to 'physicalise' things, when description at a higher level is useful for understanding or conduct, and he draws from Dennett who has described the concept of a "useful fiction" like money, which is not physically real, but it makes sense to believe in it nonetheless.
In the beginning of the article the author says that "the practical need for assuming free will is not an argument in itself.", but then every argument that follows draws precisely on the subjective need of humans to assert free will to make sense of something at a high level of abstraction.