5 ms·
I think it's a good (if inflammatory) analogy: in both cases, people are aware, in the abstract, of dangers, but systematically underestimate them by a big marg
by SilasX 8y ago
I think it's a good (if inflammatory) analogy: in both cases, people are aware, in the abstract, of dangers, but systematically underestimate them by a big margin.
People knew "smoking is bad for you", but didn't appreciate how bad.
People know "Facebook violates privacy" but not the depth of the profile they've made on you across numerous websites.
People know "You shouldn't compare yourself to others and feel bad about it", but don't realize the extent to which use of FB fights against that.
- MisterOctober 8y agoYep. I resisted FB for years, but finally gave in in ~2009 due to pressure from old school pals, after what I thought was a thorough risk/benefit analysis. Turns out that I _vastly_ underestimated the risk. I quit FB in ~2012, but not before I had already experienced some pronounced ill effects. Kind of like my auntie with smoking .
- cameronbrown 8y agoI joined Facebook in 2015 (late to the party, I know) but have never really touched Newsfeed. It's exclusively a messaging platform for me.
- throw20102010 8y agoAlso yep. Facebook is valued at $158 per user. There is absolutely no way that the average user will click on $158 worth of ads in their entire time on the platform, nor will their children, nor will their grandchildren. At some point, a sane person has to realize that Wall Street is pricing in something other than the net present value of all the ad revenue that Facebook generates. Their buildings and servers are worth peanuts to their $227 billion market cap. What the market is pricing in addition to the advertising is how Facebook sells your data to companies for uses that most people have never even considered. https://arkenea.com/blog/big-tech-companies-user-worth/ https://arkenea.com/blog/big-tech-companies-user-worth/
- itsaidpens 8y agoActually, in my experience that number is low. - Facebook Advertiser with $500k in annual spend (mice nuts actually)
- josh2600 8y agoI suspect whale users on Facebook are worth way more than $158 lifetime.
- skinnymuch 8y agoThat piece wasn’t doing proper due diligence. It used Yahoo whose value at the time was already known to be largely from Yahoo Japan and Alibaba. For Facebook it was ignoring their other assets of FBM, IG, and depending on the date, Whatsapp. Also domestic, European, other developed countries. and the rest of the world all have much different user values. Some places are barely monetized at all right now.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoI think the fundamental difference is that smoking actually shortens lives by years. On the other hand, Facebook's privacy violations have . . . made people feel a little squicky? What concrete harm has been done? Nothing to rival even a hundredth of tobacco's death toll. That's not to say we shouldn't have laws and regulations around privacy, but personally I think it's a bit of a stretch to compare Facebook and Phillip Morris.
- elefanten 8y ago1. You're only addressing the privacy component and leaving out the psychological / sociological / political components of the criticism. 2. The harms of privacy violations are hard to quantify the same way as deaths or dollars. But collapsing them down to "feeling a little squicky" vastly undershoots. There's a category of very large potential harms that come from privacy violations and littany of smaller more direct / likely harms. There is a lot of literature on this. 3. The comparison between Facebook and Phillip Morris to which you're responding was not framed in terms of deathcount or health harm. So your reading of the comparison along those lines was bound to be troubled.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y ago> 2. The harms of privacy violations are hard to quantify the same way as deaths or dollars. I'm not saying it's easy, but I am saying that no matter how you want to frame it, there's no chance it's even in the same ballpark, even with the psychosocial aspects that you rightly corrected me for ignoring. > 3. The comparison between Facebook and Phillip Morris to which you're responding was not framed in terms of deathcount or health harm. So your reading of the comparison along those lines was bound to be troubled. I think suggesting a similar policy treatment implies a certain equivalency of harm done. Whether the fine article explicitly makes that claim is beside the point, IMO.
- skinnymuch 8y agoIs it vastly undershooting compared to death? It seems like it is perfectly appropriate to say death from smoking is far far worse.
- vonnik 8y agoSocial media networks are the cigarette companies of the mind. Like Altria (which owns Philip Morris etc.), they exploit an addiction, but it's a behavioral addiction, and therefore less visible.
- adrianmonk 8y agoOne important area where the analogy doesn't work: smoking can't be done safely in moderation. Some people have trouble stopping themselves from going too far with Facebook. For example, comparing themselves to others, obsessively spending time, sharing things they shouldn't, or getting dragged into drama and fights. But for others it's entirely possible to just get on Facebook occasionally, discuss innocuous stuff, and keep in touch with people. That's not destructive or harmful. It's not a "vice" (to use the article's terminology) for me to hear that a relative is doing OK after surgery or to see that a friend enjoyed their vacation to the Rocky Mountains.
- SilasX 8y ago>One important area where the analogy doesn't work: smoking can't be done safely in moderation. Really? What are the health effects of one cigarette per month?