4 ms·
> I wonder if 'lack of crushing' can be bad for C-section births? I don't think they mentioned anything about anything in the "pro" for the deformation - in fa
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
> I wonder if 'lack of crushing' can be bad for C-section births?
I don't think they mentioned anything about anything in the "pro" for the deformation - in fact "These MRI findings suggest that the fetus is subjected to greater stress than previously thought, which could explain the high incidence of asymptomatic brain hemorrhages and retinal hemorrhages found after normal vaginal delivery."
This is something we've adapted to deal with, it's not an ideal event.
- londons_explore 8y agoThats what I mean - there might be benefits too. For example, a bit of crushing might trigger damage-response in the brain which leads to more growth. Since this has been the case for millions of years, evolution might well use what appears to be a disadvantage as an advantage in some cases. Just like there are some kinds of tree which grow better with occasional forest fires.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoThere may be, but we'll need evidence for that. Right now we just see the trauma. Not everything that nature does is a benefit - evolution is a pragmatist. Our bipedal nature and need for a big brain requires certain sacrifices to be made. Our ability to make our skulls deform enough to give birth is the only evolutionary advantage it needs to give us to justify it - it's hard to survive as a species if you can't give birth. I wouldn't make a jump to "cesareans are bad" just because it may be right, especially without any evidence from this evidence being for that, and the evidence against being "brain trauma".
- officialjunk 8y agoMy medical friends say that csection births can have complications with fluids not draining fully from the respiratory system and sinuses etc leading to infections. This is one benefit of the squishing during natural birth to help squeeze out fluids where it is no longer needed. Sorry I don’t have anything to cite. edit: misspelled “birth”
- pjc50 8y agoNot really - we've just settled into an equilibrium where our heads are as large as possible with an ""acceptable"" death rate of maternal and child death and injury from the process. (I'm reminded of one of the plot items in the Vorkosigan saga, the great feminist space opera series, which has decantable artificial wombs - the ultimate labour-saving invention.)