4 ms·
> A therapist can induce infinite demand on a patient, by just doing follow-up sessions ad-infinitum. In argentina for example, people go to the same therapist
by arcticbull 8y ago
> A therapist can induce infinite demand on a patient, by just doing follow-up sessions ad-infinitum. In argentina for example, people go to the same therapist for decades!!
You know people who take insulin are on it for the rest of their lives, but that doesn't make it the fault of their doctors.
Therapy actually works. "Hundreds of studies have found that psychotherapy is an effective way to help people make positive changes in their lives," Nordal says. "Compared with medication, psychotherapy has fewer side effects and lower instances of relapse when discontinued." [1]
> The second part is that as a patient, if the insurance covers your cost, you might as well go to the most expensive therapist you can find, and consume the infinitely. Also, you know more than the insurance company if you plan on using or needing this care, thus you have a very strong adverse-selection situation going on with any plan that is generous on mental health.
This is a very strange American perspective on health care. If it was suddenly available to everyone, there's a perception that we'd all be like kids in the candy store getting 1 of everything at the doctors office. That's just not how it works. Nobody in Canada goes to their GP and asks for the immunotherapy and a few casts. People go to doctors because they're sick, and they need treatment and would rather be literally anywhere else.
It's not as though we're socializing the electronics section at Best Buy.
> Economically speaking, mental health should not be part of an insurance scheme. It should be cash pay. To help people that could not afford mental health and they need it, you would do better to provide state-run service, that is low-cost high-effective-value and cover the lower side of the population.
Sold, but it should cover everyone.
[1] https://www.apa.org/monitor/2013/02/therapist https://www.apa.org/monitor/2013/02/therapist
- conanbatt 8y ago> You know people who take insulin are on it for the rest of their lives, but that doesn't make it the fault of their doctors. The bet on diabetes has to happen before it is diagnosed to make actuarial analysis. If you want to guarantee that all diabetes patients get access to insulin, what you want is charity, not insurance. Insurance is risk pooling. > This is a very strange American perspective on health care. If it was suddenly available to everyone, there's a perception that we'd all be like kids in the candy store getting 1 of everything at the doctors office The science has already shown that is true. Over and underutilization of healthcare are studied effects, ones insurance companies pay very close attention to because if they don't, they will go bust. That is also why countries with free healthcare also have copays. > People go to doctors because they're sick, and they need treatment and would rather be literally anywhere else. I think you are have an outsider's view on how healthcare provision works. No doctor i met would ever agree with this statement.
- arcticbull 8y ago> The bet on diabetes has to happen before it is diagnosed to make actuarial analysis. If you want to guarantee that all diabetes patients get access to insulin, what you want is charity, not insurance. Insurance is risk pooling. Yep! That's why health insurance is a misnomer. There's no guarantee my house will catch fire, so I insure against it. There is a 100% chance each and every human will catch a terminal illness. That makes it at best a structured payout program. The amount of the payout can be reduced through preventative care, and yes, maintenance drugs like insulin. That's the best case for why it should be socialized. It's not insurance, and it's not charity, it's a service in the public interest. And of course people should have access to the medication they need to live, we're not savages. > The science has already shown that is true. Over and underutilization of healthcare are studied effects, ones insurance companies pay very close attention to because if they don't, they will go bust. That is also why countries with free healthcare also have copays. Insurance companies get paid in advance, and their goal is not to provide the best care but to return the largest amount possible to their shareholders. Co-pays keep people out of hospital, especially lower-income folks, which allows insurance companies to make more money. Same with high deductibles. Their goal is not care, it's profit. The UK and Canada (the systems I know best) don't really have co-payments, certainly not like in the US. The vast majority of services are co-payment free [1] (UK: "Out-of-pocket payments for general practice are limited to some services, such as examinations for employment or insurance purposes and the provision of certificates for travel or insurance", in Ontario going to the hospital you only pay for parking or 'upgrades' like private rooms - [2], [3] is the entire fee schedule). Same with Australia [4] who in 2015 rebelled over an AU$7 co-pay. You get sick, you go to the doctor, they take care of it. Think about it, if you could access any procedure right now, what would you get done? Nothing, because it's not fun, it's not rewarding. If it's medically necessary, you'll get it done one way or the other, if it's not, literally why are you at the hospital? Yes, use goes up a bit. IMO, that can be offset by creating clinics and guiding people to them for minor ailments as in the UK. > I think you are have an outsider's view on how healthcare provision works. No doctor i met would ever agree with this statement. Respectfully disagree. Both my parents are doctors, and I grew up in numerous medical systems all over the world. I've benefitted hugely from socialized medical systems and not having one right now is downright terrifying even though I'm well 'insured'. My dad refused to work in the US because he felt the healthcare system here was inhumane. He wanted to provide people care based on their needs not what they could afford. It took me until I lived here to understand he was exactly right. There's a lot of this apologist: "there must be some reason the American system is better" -- sorry, it's just not better. [1] https://international.commonwealthfund.org/countries/england/ https://international.commonwealthfund.org/countries/england... [2] https://www.qch.on.ca/hospitalcharges https://www.qch.on.ca/hospitalcharges [3] https://www.qch.on.ca/uploads/Finance/Hospital%20fees%20Website%20version%20for%20Insured%20Res%20April%201%202019%20NewLogo.pdf https://www.qch.on.ca/uploads/Finance/Hospital%20fees%20Webs... [4] https://transferwise.com/au/blog/healthcare-system-in-australia https://transferwise.com/au/blog/healthcare-system-in-austra...