4 ms·
Our immigration system is to benefit Americans (a better economy is good for Americans). We don’t have the responsibility to make things better in other countr
by mc32 8y ago
Our immigration system is to benefit Americans (a better economy is good for Americans). We don’t have the responsibility to make things better in other countries. It’s their government’s responsibility, not ours. Now, if they want to become the fifty first state in the union and we go thru the process and bring them in, ok.
- ggggtez 8y agoIf you take the step to agree that this would bias towards wealthy people, I'd take the next step and argue there isn't really evidence that letting only wealthy people become citizens actually makes the US a better place. "Give me your cold, your tired, your huddled masses yearning to be free". Being an American isn't just about capitalism.
- mc32 8y agoThat’s a private poem, not a government policy, never was. We have a responsibility towards fellow Americans. If the Chinese have a bias against people from their countryside, it’s not up to us to fix their mess. We want people who can come here and contribute, not be welfare for them because their own country isn’t doing the right thing. We would not be doing “the right thing” by Americans if we subsidized this either.
- ng12 8y ago> "Give me your cold, your tired, your huddled masses yearning to be free" That poem was written one year after the Chinese Exclusion Act was passed. We really need to stop using it as justification for anything.
- challenger22 8y agoThere is plenty of evidence that wealthy people are better citizens. They commit less crime, are more economically productive, and consume more goods and services from other people, thereby boosting the economy. A nation that only accepts wealthy immigrants would be a nation with less of the problems associated with poverty. The questions are more like: 1. is this fair? and 2. would the reduction in number of immigrants be harmful to economic growth?
- kthejoker2 8y agoIt's like you didn't even read the post you responded to....
- challenger22 8y agoPoverty is not a unique property of capitalism.
- ggggtez 8y agoYou aren't really engaging with the point I'm making. You are thinking in this close minded "What are the Q3 earnings"-sort of way. What if there is something deep down, something idealistic like "Equality" and "Freedom" that should actually be a right for every person on earth? That you shouldn't have to have a Harvard education to claim? Isn't the USA the place that promises that opportunity? That you can strive and work hard, and make a better life for yourself and your family? I'm not saying kick out the doctors and ceos, but being a doctor or ceo should not be the bar for entering the US.
- nlarew 8y agoI don't think jedberg's point is that we have a responsibility to make things better in other countries. Rather, I think the point is that if we only focus on indicators of "merit" that correlate with wealth we'll miss out on valuable, smart people who want to come to the US from a less wealthy background.
- mc32 8y agoI think they are using “skills” as a proxy for wealth. As such this poor person with skills to them is being proxied as “wealthy”. Our system doesn’t care. We care that they have skills to bring to the table.
- octernion 8y agogenerally most merit systems use education as a proxy for "skills" and jedberg is (aptly) noting that this is generally a proxy for wealth and not for capability/skills across the broader populace.
- mc32 8y agoLet’s say that ends up being the case. It’s their govs responsibility to set up programs to promote those people to us, not ours to hunt them down. I don’t see why it’s our responsibility to do “equal opportunity” to a foreign population we have no responsibility for. We have this responsibility for our own population, yes, but others are out of scope completely.