7 ms·
Even before the insurance denies, it is basically impossible to get someone that is delusional/psychotic mental health care in the US, unless they go in volunta
by hedora 8y ago
Even before the insurance denies, it is basically impossible to get someone that is delusional/psychotic mental health care in the US, unless they go in voluntarily, which they won’t, by the nature of the illness.
A friend that has been certified mentally ill stopped taking his meds and was fantasizing about killing himself, a family member and shooting up religious organizations. His doctor, family, employer and friends all called the police, talked to lawyers, mental health professionals, etc.
The end result was that he was facing sleeping in a car that was about to repossessed, and eating in homeless shelters. At that point he decided to accept free housing in exchange for seeking help.
His family’s only other recourse would have been to pay tens of thousands of dollars in legal fees to petition the court to force the police to uphold the law. This would have had a medium to low chance of succeeding.
Of course, during the months this dragged on, he missed an insurance payment or two (he had also been fired, divorced and evicted), so it lapsed.
There is a 12 (6?) month wait to get government disability insurance to kick in for this sort of thing, and the clock starts after the mentally ill person goes in for scary interviews with the government to establish they’re actually crazy.
The law used to handle this sort of thing properly in California, but Regan repealed the lions share of it as governor, and loopholes that accidentally allowed people like my friend to get health care have been progressively closed since them.
Nurses at the intake office of the appropriate mental health facility in Santa Cruz told me that most of the homeless people in the Boardwalk area there are in exactly the same situation as my friend was in, except they’ve been trapped in it for years.
- sokoloff 8y ago> it is basically impossible to get someone that is delusional/psychotic mental health care in the US, unless they go in voluntarily I'm not sure I see a better solution to this that doesn't come with its own set of risks and downsides (involuntary commitment or counseling of someone against their will is not something to be taken lightly in any event, even if their reality diverges from your own).
- maxerickson 8y agoThe current approach is not a solution, it's doing very little and saying you are doing something. Describing psychotic delusions as 'reality diverges' is something or other, I have to say. Of course we need to respect the rights of individuals, but it shouldn't be the case that family and friends are the first, second, third, fourth and so on interventions, there can be professional resources available.
- dsr_ 8y agoThings which would have helped here: - healthcare not linked to employment - a housing-first homeless policy - a compassionate aid policy that presumes that people who are asking for help need help, and starts providing help as soon as it is asked for rather than after a year or more. Those don't seem like they have any major risks other than monetary.
- sokoloff 8y agoWhat do any of those have to do with a patient who refuses to go in voluntarily for treatment?
- sambull 8y agoThey can foster hope, and try to strive for happiness without struggles of a simple toothache, crippling debt and outright usurious lending practices, while emptying a cold can of chili into chip bag on bus bench for breakfast.
- hedora 8y agoI strongly disagree with the housing first policy. I tried paying for temporary housing for my friend, and things spiraled. The housing has to be conditioned on some sort of recovery plan. Threat of homelessness is basically the only remaining lever the law allows in these situations. The other two points are spot on.
- Frondo 8y agoI don't know your circumstances, and first of all that is a great and generous thing you did for your friend. The one place I know of where a housing-first policy has been implemented, Salt Lake City (or maybe all of Utah?), doesn't just give homeless people a set of keys. They do assign everyone a social worker at the same time. The goal is to minimize the risk of what happened to your friend; that isn't good for anyone, including the person spiraling. It's key, though, to start with a home (and a social worker). The wealthiest country in the world can do that for its people -- and it shouldn't be on private citizens, though that was generous of you.
- hedora 8y agoI believe the previous solution was to err on the side of allowing 24-hour involuntary psychiatric holds, with observation by a neutral doctor, and taking abuses of that extremely seriously. In my friend’s case, he had actually set up permissions for the doctor, his family, and I to initiate such a thing, but after his episode started, he fired his doctor and was quiet for a month, which nullified the paperwork he had done to create a safety net for himself. The law has a list of things that have to happen before the psychiatric hold if there is not such an arrangement. Basically, the mental illness has to affect some number of life areas. I think this is the list, I might be remembering wrong: - work - finances - shelter - self care (eating, etc) - family life / marriage. It used to be that one thing on the list was sufficient. I think the current law is that a total of three are necessary, but not sufficient. Risk of immediate self harm or harming others is a different path, but the person basically has to say “yes, I do plan to kill myself, or that fellow over there, officer” on camera for that to count. Anyway, my friend ticked all six of these boxes, and that wasn’t sufficient. If the person is borderline coherent, don’t think anything really is. (Nothing in this message should be considered medical or legal advice. Go talk to a doctor and a lawyer if you might need to know any of this stuff, especially if everyone is healthy at the moment.) (Edit: upvoted sokoloff because this is exactly what everyone with any power to provide care says.)
- task_queue 8y ago> I believe the previous solution was to err on the side of allowing 24-hour involuntary psychiatric holds, with observation by a neutral doctor, and taking abuses of that extremely seriously. We have a history of using this policy in multiple countries, and in each one the system was abused to torment and commit minorities, people (including children) who were deemed an inconvenience, and political enemies. I say this as someone with a family member who went through a very similar experience as your friend. I know just how scary and frustrating it is, and the immense burden of care and worrying it puts on people who care about someone going through mental breakdown like that. I wish there was a solution to this problem, but I don't know what it would look like.
- fjsolwmv 8y ago
- jvagner 8y agoIMO-- In so many ways, America needs to start understanding that solutions to these problems have been explored and, just possibly, greater progress achieved in other countries... progress can be gleaned by studying outcomes from those countries. It's easy to dismiss suggestions as having "its own set of risks and downsides", but in critical areas, America is significantly underperforming other first world countries and we need to get past the Not Invented Here syndrome.
- WalterSear 8y agoIt's not Not Invented Here syndrome. It's Indoctrinated That Anything Socialized Is For Weak Moochers And Cannot Succeed Because It's Not Capitalism syndrome.
- DanBC 8y agoIn England you have an assessment with an AMHP (who is there to protect the rights of the patient) and two doctors. One is a specialist MH doctor with training on the law, the other knows the patient. They have to agree that the patient poses a serious risk of harm to themselves or other people, and that they must be detained in hospital for assessment or treatment. The AMHP asks the patient's nearest relative if they object to the section -- if they do object it becomes harder to detain someone. You then provide free legal advice, and access to mental health act tribunals where people can challenge their detention. You have independent regulators who provide some oversight, the rpess can report on it all, and of course the courts provide a final backstop. There are problems with this, but it's pretty good. We have short detentions for assessment. We have longer detentions for treatment. We have police powers to take someone from a public place to a place of safety for assessment. There's another police power where the police can take someone from their home to a place of safety for assessment, but only if they have a valid warrant.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chaostheory 8y ago> Most of the homeless people in the Boardwalk area there are in exactly the same situation as my friend was in, except they’ve been trapped in it for years Most cities & states just try to fix the symptoms of homelessness (& crime), and not the actual root of the problem. There needs to be a federal mental health program to handle this, and maybe states & cities will stop playing 'hot potato', shipping them back and forth to be someone else's problem
- fjsolwmv 8y agoThe try to fix the symptoms that inpaxt wealthy people's confort and property values, more specifically. Not the symptoms that impact the poor and homeless.
- kosys 8y agoThis isn't the case in all states. I knew a friend who was LGBT and bullied severely where she was falsely arrested by hearsay of the persons bullying her. She ended up being brought to a hospital because of lies and was forcibly committed because of the police report that was written from testimony of the people who bullied her. She ended up committing suicide later in life because of the hospital experience and where none of the doctors listened to her with labeling her delusional. I don't know if they drugged her because she never went into detail about it.
- jhauris 8y agoThis is the kind of thing that worries me. I'd rather err on the side of not involuntarily removing people's freedom.
- arcticbull 8y agoThere's a big difference between offering socialized mental health care to anyone who needs it and forcing people to take it. It's like saying we shouldn't offer socialized medical care because the government may drag me in to the doctors office and force me to wear a cast. I do understand the negative connotations and our checkered past with mental healthcare in general though I'd like to think we've come a long way and we should address failures on a case-by-case basis.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoThe slippery slope is real though. In the UK relatively minor infractions have gotten babies seized from their mothers, not for criminal justification but for health department reasons.
- briandear 8y agoHere are some facts about the popular myth that Reagan caused the problem: https://www.nytimes.com/1984/10/30/science/how-release-of-mental-patients-began.html https://www.nytimes.com/1984/10/30/science/how-release-of-me...
- soup10 8y agoLots of people do voluntarily check themselves into mental health facilities, but can you really blame those that don't want to be locked in ward with unstable people with nothing to do while being force fed antipsychotics and mood stabilizers.
- openasocket 8y agoMy father is a clinical psychologist, and he's got a bunch of stories like this. Parents going from doctor to doctor with all of their children's records, begging someone to get them off the street. It really is a tragedy. Often, their only hope is to hope their child commits a minor crime, gets arrested (and hopefully not shot), and is then declared mentally unfit to stand trial.
- turk73 8y agoReagan left the governorship in 1975. Do you even listen to yourself? Please. Liberals are the ones that got the mental hospitals shut down. Let's not rewrite history. Regardless, there is nothing stopping the California legislature and governor from reversing that 44 year old policy.
- lamarpye 8y agoApparently Reagan was Governor 43 years ago. Why haven't the various Democratic Governors and Legislatures since Reagan addressed the problem?
- droithomme 8y ago> but Regan repealed the lions share of it as governor Reagan was elected governor over FIFTY YEARS AGO. Why not blame Julius Caesar, or George Washington, instead?