2 ms·
> While TESS doesn’t yet have enough planets in its statistics bin to confirm or disprove the Fulton gap, You can stop reading the article after that line.
by ekianjo 8y ago
> While TESS doesn’t yet have enough planets in its statistics bin to confirm or disprove the Fulton gap,
You can stop reading the article after that line.
- sidlls 8y agoWhy? A key part of physics is collecting data. All the line means is the data are incomplete but as of now suggest a gap that may be interesting to keep an eye on as new data are observed.
- scott_s 8y agoYes, agreed. We now have a prediction. We will collect more data to see if that prediction holds. If it does, we'll work on theories to explain it. (Of course, these two processes will actually happen in tandem, as how things work in practice is much messier.) They are not looking at the data set and saying "This anomaly will certainly hold when we get more data, it is now established fact." They are looking at the data set and saying "This looks funny, we should keep an eye on it." That is good science.
- jerf 8y agoI actually find it hard to imagine the model of science that some people seem to have is supposed to work, where, apparently, you are supposed to never look at the real data already collected out in the world and somehow just come up with hypotheses to be tested from... uhh... err... nothing, apparently, because looking at pre-existing data is somehow cheating, and, what else is there? The "standard model" of science that seems to be embedded in the heads of the Greater Internet Commetariat is pretty ludicrously nonsensical in a number of places.
- ekianjo 8y agoIf your data sample is far from being significant you don't jump to conclusions or ridiculous hypotheses. For example, if you roll a dice just 10 times and find out that 6 does not come out at all, do you jump to "scientists wonder why 6 never comes up. There must be something we don't understand". No, you just did not collect enough data, that is all.
- abakker 8y agoThere's more to life than statistical significance. We all act on lots of qualitative information all the time, and it doesn't cause us to be catastrophic morons. In fact, we spend inordinate amounts of time trying to teach computers to be good at understanding those qualitative differences.
- rory096 8y agoTESS was launched last year and saw first light on August 7. Most existing data comes from Kepler and terrestrial observations.