3 ms·
> Would growing a lot of plants help perhaps? It doesn't help much unless there are many plants in a small contained area. All the studies, including NASA one
by lm28469 8y ago
> Would growing a lot of plants help perhaps?
It doesn't help much unless there are many plants in a small contained area.
All the studies, including NASA ones, are done in sealed environments, as soon as you test them in real life you basically need to fill the room with plants.
Air filtering is hard to do right, consume a lot of energy and/or requires filters that have to be changed often. If we were logical we'd straight up ban cars in our city centers, which would remove most of the pollution in 1st world countries' cities.
----- from : https://www.gardenmyths.com/garden-myth-born-plants-dont-purify-air/ https://www.gardenmyths.com/garden-myth-born-plants-dont-pur...
The NASA study shows that plants remove a small amount of certain chemicals from the air. A 1500 sq ft home would need around 400 large plants to remove most of the tested chemicals–something that is not practical. Reports that list the best plants for the job are probably not valid lists. The microbes in the soil of the pot are more efficient at removing chemicals than the plants themselves.
Reporters who write about the ability of plants to remove pollutants either have not read the reference they quote (most likely case) or they have cherry picked the data that suits their story. Most have probably just reported what previous reporters said. The original reporters made the following mistakes:
ignored the lab conditions used to carry out the experiments
used the very best number in the report, ie 90%, and extrapolated it to all plants and all chemicals
extrapolated results for 3 chemicals to “all pollutants”
completely ignored the scientists own conclusions, namely microbes and charcoal filters remove most of the chemicals
- vanderZwan 8y agoThat's what I was afraid of. At least I live in a city with relatively little air pollution. Makes me miss Groningen though (which has a car-free city centre, and it makes a difference). Well, here's to hoping electric cars take off quickly.