3 ms·
> Isn't it a crime to accuse someone falsely? That's not really applicable here, because Hertz doesn't seem to have accused anyone. It sounds like Hertz, eithe
by tzs 8y ago
> Isn't it a crime to accuse someone falsely?
That's not really applicable here, because Hertz doesn't seem to have accused anyone. It sounds like Hertz, either due to badly designed procedures or employees taking shortcuts, can lose track of which car a renter has been loaned.
This leads them to find that a car that their system says is not rented out and so should be on the lot is missing [1]. They then report that missing car to the police.
The person with the car gets detained and maybe arrested because they were found in possession of property reported missing by the owner, not because they were accused of anything by Hertz. So at most Hertz would face civil liability under some kind of negligence theory.
[1] In most of these cases, the same lot with the missing car should also have an extra car present that their records say is out with a renter, so the total number of cars in the lot should match their records. There should be a sanity check somewhere that says if the total is correct, but a car is "missing", then they should identify the extra car, contact the renter who supposedly is out driving it around, and find out if that person somehow got the missing car.
- yholio 8y ago> They then report that missing car to the police. We're playing with words. That's an implicit accusation, our car is missing and we believe someone stole it. Furthermore, the last person to rent it out was X. I'm sure you can spin this around legally, but the spirit of the interdiction against false accusations applies, one should not be able to play with the power of law enforcement and cry 'wolf' in jest, it's a critical public resource with grave consequences.
- mikeash 8y agoAccording to the articles, the cars were reported stolen, not “missing.”