4 ms·
I occasionally make comments supporting the basic actions of the government based on the data available which are wildly unpopular. This time something differe
by colechristensen 8y ago
I occasionally make comments supporting the basic actions of the government based on the data available which are wildly unpopular.
This time something different: why do people support Manning's decision / find her treatment inappropriate?
Respect for sticking up for beliefs? I get that and share those feelings even if I don't share the specific beliefs.
But do people feel the 5th Amendment covers "incriminating" yourself after you've been convicted and served time (and don't have any risk of further convictions)?
Do people want the 5th to include incriminating people you like?
What specifically about the grand jury system in place here do you think is problematic or unconstitutional?
- yardie 8y agoGrand juries are secret and procedurally unnecessary. They are trying to drum up enough evidence to go to real trial. The fact that their grand jury exploration rests entirely on her testimony means the prosecution’s case is fairly weak as it stands. she’s being jailed on an option.
- michaelt 8y agoOften there is a widely held, low-resolution understanding of the constitution, and when you get into the high-resolution details there are exceptions that seem like the complete opposite of the widely held understanding. For example, a naive reading of the commerce clause would say the fact Congress can regulate commerce among the states would not apply to a farmer growing wheat to feed animals on his own farm. But surprise! Wickard v. Filburn [1] says that counts as interstate commerce. Likewise, the low-resolution understanding of the fifth amendment is that you can't be forced to testify; and the low-resolution understanding of being granted immunity for something is you can't be sent to jail for reasons related to it. And yet, here we are. A lot of Americans like the constitution - so much so, everyone in congress and the military and suchlike swears an oath to uphold and defend it. When people see these things that are a reversal of what they understand the constitution to say, it's understandable they don't like it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn
- emilfihlman 8y agoWhy should I be required to say anything to the government? It's my speech and it's protected.
- travmatt 8y agoReading more of the opinions here makes it fairly clear that the people holding said opinions don’t really have any understanding about the reason Manning is being held in contempt, or any real understanding of the American legal system. Most seem to have typed “why grand juries are bad” into google and are repeating nuanced positions in ways that don’t really fit.