4 ms·
Could she just testify and say "I don't remember." and "I don't understand." all the time? That's pretty much what all CEOs and such do when they are testifyin
by scotty79 8y ago
Could she just testify and say "I don't remember." and "I don't understand." all the time?
That's pretty much what all CEOs and such do when they are testifying.
- ak39 8y agoThat’s weaseling out. She isn’t doing that here even though she could. She just doesn’t want to do that because I imagine she is principled. That’s honorable.
- scotty79 8y agoI don't argue with that. But that's one silly law that judge can compel you to talk but you can easily weasel your way out of it by saying things that might be true and give no information. I think such law shouldn't exist as it can only harm only truthful, principled people but can do nothing to any wrongdoer.
- trickstra 8y agoIn principle, wrongdoers always have more options available than moral people. Because being moral prevents you from using some ways that would be considered immoral, while the wrongdoers don't have those restrictions, therefore can and will weasel out. In the movies the good side wins even despite this limitation, then heroes are celebrated for their morality and bravery, but in the real life... well...
- nullc 8y ago> That’s weaseling out. It would in many ways be the only honest answer. The facts in question are almost a decade ago now. Chelsea is now in many senses a different person. The fine details of her comments could result in the execution of another person. Anyone who is confident of the fine details from events ten years ago before experiencing a multitude of bad experiences is probably significantly overconfident in their recollection.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 8y agoI understood she is making a statement by refusing. She said that she has said everything there is to be said. It's like a hunger strike.
- gppk 8y agoI read something a while back that said you generally can't do that if it can be shown that you could remember. No idea how that works in practice though.
- elliekelly 8y agoCorrect. The attorney doing the questioning will have additional supporting evidence... documents, transcripts of prior testimony, established timelines of events, etc. So if they ask “were you at [location] on [date]?” and she replied “I don’t remember” they would simply show her evidence of her being at that location on that date to “refresh her recollection” and then she would be expected to answer. She could answer along the lines of “from this [evidence] it looks like I was” but it would be difficult if not impossible to avoid answering questions altogether.
- trickstra 8y agoBut it forces the other party to have evidence for everything. The point of the questioning is to gain additional evidence from the answers. But if all answers are "If that's what it says, then that's what it says" as Richard Sackler https://youtu.be/-qCKR6wy94U?t=952 https://youtu.be/-qCKR6wy94U?t=952 then it's apparently the effective way to go
- elliekelly 8y agoRight, it definitely makes it more difficult but keep in mind that you don’t need to gain additional information in order to gather additional evidence. For example, if I have a piece of paper - Exhibit A, that demonstrates you were at a certain place at a certain time, that’s definitely valuable evidence but at trial opposing counsel could call into question the source of the document, chain of custody, or a number of other issues to contest its accuracy and/or validity. But if I have you on the stand and show you that piece of paper and you say, on the record, that it does seem like you were there, now I have Exhibit B - a record of your testimony, at the very least admitting the document seems legitimate and reliable. But most jurors would take your statement as pretty close to an admission. Exhibit B is highly valuable because it’s almost impossible for your lawyer to contest. As entertainingly frustrating as Sackler’s deposition was his responses were indeed some of the least valuable he could have possibly provided. I’m sure that was part of his legal team’s preparation for the meeting. “If that’s what it says then that’s what it says” is a meaningless tautology. But keeping up that sort of response throughout an entire line of questioning is difficult even in a deposition and takes a certain amount of IDGAF attitude that Sackler clearly has in spades. A deposition is also a bit different from the grand jury testimony Chelsea Manning would have given because a deposition isn’t a courtroom proceeding. Responses like Sackler’s wouldn’t fly if he were in front of a Judge.
- thinkingemote 8y agoYou can turn up at court but you don't have to be compelled to say things. In the UK "no comment" works to all questions except confirmation of one's identity.
- maxlybbert 8y ago“I don’t remember” is a fine answer only if it’s true. Otherwise she could be punished for making false statements (the issue is how to prove someone actually does remember). In court, she could just invoke the Fifth Amendment, but I don’t know whether that applies to grand jury proceedings, especially since the grand jury isn’t investigating her and she’s already served time for any crimes she committed.
- bitwize 8y agoYou can only invoke the Fifth Amendment if what you say would incriminate yourself. Chelsea is here being compelled to give evidence against other people. Also, if she were lying she could be charged with perjury.
- trickstra 8y agoit works for others, so why not here? https://youtu.be/-qCKR6wy94U?t=1121 https://youtu.be/-qCKR6wy94U?t=1121