5 ms·
I don't see any mention of an offer of immunity. If I didn't have immunity, you can be damn sure I wouldn't be answering any questions on a subject that might
by bsder 8y ago
I don't see any mention of an offer of immunity.
If I didn't have immunity, you can be damn sure I wouldn't be answering any questions on a subject that might get me prosecuted again.
- red_trumpet 8y agoYeah, how can they force her to testify if that would mean incriminating herself? Though I'm not a lawyer, this seems to contradict my idea of a [Rechtsstaat](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rechtsstaat?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rechtsstaat?wprov=sfla1).
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThe article has a quotation that suggests there was immunity: We "never once made this about anything other than obtaining immunized testimony in furtherance of an investigation," he said, adding that "all we want is her to truthfully answer questions as our constitutional republic requires of our citizens."
- tssva 8y agoThey can't force her to testify if it would incriminate herself. That isn't what is happening here. If she has been offered immunity then she can't incriminate herself. Also answering questions regarding an offense she has already been convicted of isn't incriminating herself. If during her testimony she believes that answering a specific question would incriminate herself she can refuse to answer it upon that basis. What she can't legally do is refuse to answer any questions whatsoever.
- shakna 8y ago> We "never once made this about anything other than obtaining immunized testimony in furtherance of an investigation," he said, adding that "all we want is her to truthfully answer questions as our constitutional republic requires of our citizens." Immunity does appear to be on the table as part of the request, though I'm not sure why you would browbeat someone into testifying with jailtime and threats that amount to bankruptcy if you aren't seeking to entrap them in some fashion.
- Kalium 8y agoThe public has a claim to every person's evidence. If a person has evidence that a court of law wishes to obtain, under American law the court is permitted to compel immunized testimony. Someone who refuses to comply is likely to be treated as someone who has committed an act of contempt of court. Chelsea Manning isn't special here. Anyone who refuses to testify before a grand jury is likely to be treated this way. There's no need to postulate that it's a further attempt to punish someone for political reasons to explain all events here.
- kazagistar 8y agoThe public is laughable here. It's a small cabal working entirely in their own self interest, using the power they have to punish those who challenged it. Its disgusting to bring up the public good.
- shakna 8y agoI don't see any need to call her as a witness here. Her testimony is on file, and some parts of it are even a matter of public record. She has already extensively testified in the past. In most court cases, there is a wish to limit the number of witnesses in a case. Where you can take testimony by reports, affidavits, and other records, you take it, as it speeds up the process considerably. The only reason to call Manning is if you believe that you can show that new testimony conflicts with old testimony.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoSo she is not testifying because she doesn't want to repeat herself? That seems silly. No, there is something she doesn't want to say, because it would incriminate someone she doesn't want to incriminate. I doubt it's herself.
- shakna 8y agoI haven't expressed any opinion on why Manning has made the choices they have. I may or may not agree. I have questions for the court, because they have chosen to act in a way that doesn't seem to follow standard procedure. My query is one of legal practice.
- throw20102010 8y agoI don't think it's about that. Chelsea already served a prison term for stealing classified documents. President Obama commuted the sentence, but did not pardon her, so she's already been convicted and served her entire sentence. Because of double jeopardy, she can't be tried again for stealing those documents, and I don't think she's done anything else that's criminal. I think this is about not supporting what she feels is supporting an unjust and corrupt system. I don't blame her. I doubt that I would act the same way, but she felt strongly enough about the Army's actions in Iraq to break the law while fully aware of the consequences. She's probably got the guts to keep her word when she says she has ethical concerns about the grand jury and won't be answering any questions.
- boucher 8y agoPeople who testify to grand juries are automatically granted immunity with respect to that testimony, unless it is explicitly waived. That automatic immunity negates their right to invoke the 5th amendment under the law.
- narag 8y agoWild guess: she's asked to testify about Assange. Assuming he's guilty, either she incriminates him or lies. Lying to the jury wouldn't be covered by immunity, would it?
- boucher 8y agoNo, lying would not be covered.
- silversconfused 8y agoNothing to gain, everything to lose. She's doing the right thing. Huge self sacrifice.