3 ms·
The problem with "save in good times, spend in bad" is that people don't actually save in good times. Even if you raise interest rates, people will still borrow
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
The problem with "save in good times, spend in bad" is that people don't actually save in good times. Even if you raise interest rates, people will still borrow money when times are good because that's when there's profit to be made by investing the borrowed money. They do it less when rates are higher, but they still do it.
The "problem" with the natural cycle is that in bad times people start to default on their debts, which would otherwise cause banks to raise rates to account for the higher risk, which would cause even more defaults. By central banks lowering rates at those times you prevent that from happening, but at the cost of ballooning everyone's debt out of control. Because then people affected by the downturn can borrow even more money at the low rates. So we borrow in good times and borrow even more in bad times. Real debt per capita has been increasing for decades, which obviously isn't sustainable.
But that's what Keynesianism does -- it defers a crash by allowing otherwise uncreditworthy people to take on additional debt rather than filing for bankruptcy, but nobody ever pays the debt back.
Now the problem is times are good except that everybody has too much debt, which is only fine because interest rates are low. Raise them and everything falls apart as the money people are currently using to buy stuff and live their lives is suddenly required to make interest payments on existing debt.
What we need at this point is for people to pay off their debts. But they can't, because the money they borrowed is now inside corporations that never spend it.
So we need to either find a way for that money to get out of corporations and back into the hands of regular people (without crashing the stock market), or print a bunch of new money that isn't derived from debt and give that to regular people so they can use that to pay back their debts with.
- 2reach1 8y ago> 'What we need at this point is people paying off their debt!' Debt... ('contextless OT) ...shortage... damn! Just for a second i remembered a picture of the historic, ancient egypt, where organs were 'weighted' - and that the last time i had seen it, was in the movie repo men ^^ > [P-:] //wiki/Repo_Man_(film)
- AstralStorm 8y agoYou missed an option C: forgive the debt (like default but less consequences) but keep companies and people accountable for externalities with really tight control.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoOption C is a moral hazard and is fundamentally unfair. If everybody gets a UBI and people in debt use that to pay it off, people not in debt still get the same amount of money. Loan forgiveness is wrong because it doesn't work that way. If you paid your student loans and I didn't because I decided to buy a Tesla instead, should I have my loans forgiven when you had to pay yours? If I bought a house on credit while you rent an apartment, I get my mortgage forgiven but you have to keep paying rent? If I bought a million dollar house I couldn't afford and you bought a $250K house you could, I get rewarded for living beyond my means? Give everybody the same amount in cash.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoCould you please lend me half a million for a couple of years?
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThat's not what Keynesianism does. Keynesianism is countercyclical stimulus spending which boosts the economy in general by increasing activity, balanced by higher taxes which prevent overheating. The last decade or two haven't been Keynesian at all - they've been selective corporate welfare for the financial sector, combined with a bizarre implication that this will somehow trickle down into the economy as a whole, combined with very anti-Keynesian low taxation for the beneficiaries. The effects are as you describe, but more for common sense reason than Keynesian ones. Financial actors who were some combination of bankrupt, inefficient, and corrupt were bailed out and Frankensteined into continued growth when they should have been left to die on the slab. The result has been a fragile debt, leverage, and froth extraction economy, tentpoled - for now - by a few giant tech monopolies.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Keynesianism is countercyclical stimulus spending which boosts the economy in general by increasing activity, balanced by higher taxes which prevent overheating. As implemented by the Fed it means lowering interest rates during downturns to stimulate spending on credit and raising interest rates during times of exuberance to cool things off. But the result of that is that everyone is always getting further into debt, because it's the bad times when people would otherwise normally have either defaulted or paid the debts back (to avoid what would otherwise be higher risk-driven interest rates at those times, compared to the then-lower investment returns from the borrowed money). So by stimulating borrowing during recessions, debt increases significantly then instead of being reduced. Meanwhile it still doesn't get paid back during the good times because the higher rates reduce borrowing during those times but nobody really wants them so high during times of productive business opportunities that people divert money from growing businesses to paying back old debts. So consumer debt goes up but never down. The corollary on the government side only works because "high taxes" rather than "high interest rates" actually increases government revenue, which gives them something to pay the public debt back with. (Assuming that's what they did with the money, which it isn't -- and can't be with the Fed doing the opposite, because paying back government debt in good times would lower interest rates then.) But on the consumer side, higher interest rates reduce the amount of money people have to pay back debts with rather than increase it. And so do higher taxes. Which leaves the way out as the government creating new money and giving it to people so that they have something to pay their debts with. Then it doesn't come from taxes, so you aren't just taking money from people to give it back to them (or crashing the stock market by taking it from businesses), and it doesn't come from issuing more government debt, so you aren't increasing interest rates and causing people to have to pay the money they receive as interest rather than principal (or crashing the stock market again).
- 2reach1 8y ago> 'What we need at this point is people paying off their debt!' Debt... ('contextless OT') ...shortage... damn! Just for a second i remembered a picture of the historic, ancient egypt, where organs were 'weighted' - and that the last time i had seen it, was in the movie repo men ^^ > [P-:] //wiki/Repo_Man_(film)