3 ms·
What to do with nuclear waste is a solved problem: you reprocess it. That gives you more fuel (since much of the "waste" is actually unburned fuel) and reduces
by pdonis 8y ago
What to do with nuclear waste is a solved problem: you reprocess it. That gives you more fuel (since much of the "waste" is actually unburned fuel) and reduces the radioactivity of what's left over to easily manageable levels. Every other country that uses nuclear power does this; the US didn't do it for decades for political reasons.
- stephenr 8y agoSo, Nuclear, which is already arguably more expensive than renewables, to become even remotely "clean", would cost even more... Sure sounds like a great plan.
- pfdietz 8y agoNo, actually most countries that use nuclear power don't reprocess. Some send their waste to France to be reprocessed, but even that is becoming a problem. France's reprocessing effort is (they have admitted) a net economic loss. It doesn't reduce the cost of waste disposal, it increases it. And when France reprocesses someone's waste, like Japan, they send back the plutonium. Japan now has enough reactor grade Pu to make thousands of bombs. It's not ideal for making bombs, but it can be made to work. For Japan, reprocessing has been a kind of plausibly deniable nuclear proliferation. They have the material to become a nuclear armed nation in a big way, and quickly, should they ever decide to do that.
- pdonis 8y ago> most countries that use nuclear power don't reprocess Most countries don't reprocess spent nuclear fuel immediately on removing it from the reactor. They store it until it is economical to reprocess it--because reprocessing turns most of the spent fuel into new fuel. So of course it doesn't make sense to reprocess it until doing so is cheaper than just buying new fuel on the market. The point of reprocessing is not to get rid of all the waste immediately, but to reduce the required storage time from something totally unrealistic like 10,000 years to something totally realistic like 30 to 50 years--in other words, enough time for the market price of new fuel to exceed the cost of reprocessing the spent fuel you have stored. In other words, reprocessing is simply part of a sane long-term plan for the nuclear fuel cycle. But of course the people who are against nuclear power are not against it for sane reasons, so you wouldn't expect them to understand a sane long-term plan.
- pfdietz 8y agoNo, most don't reprocess. Most don't even have the facilities for reprocessing. Some send their fuel to France for reprocessing, but the french admit this is not economically rational to do. Reprocessing is a net economic loser (and that's why there's no reprocessing in the US, not because of prohibitions that were removed long ago). It's cheaper to just make new fuel from uranium. This is because uranium turned out to be more abundant than feared, nuclear power growth stalled, fabricating fuel elements with mixed oxides is more expensive because of TRU toxicity, and because the cost of enrichment went WAY down when the world switched from gaseous diffusion to centrifuges. Reprocessing does not significantly reduce the cost of disposal, especially if fast reactors are not being used. Thermal reactors can tolerate maybe one go around of the fuel, but you then end up with more transuranics like curium that have higher thermal output, which limits how tightly they can be packed in an underground repository. And fast reactors are expensive, so using them doesn't make this an easier sell. Countries have not foreclosed the possibility of reprocessing in the future, but (aside from it being a kind of deniable weapon material proliferation) it's difficult to see why they would ever want to.
- pdonis 8y ago> Reprocessing is a net economic loser Yes, because, as you state, the current cost of new fuel is lower than the cost of reprocessing. But that won't always be true. If we start building significantly more nuclear capacity, it probably won't be true for more than 30 to 50 years.
- pfdietz 8y agoYou seem to have abandoned your claim "every other country that uses nuclear power reprocesses the spent fuel". This fictional reprocessing seems to have been moved off into the future. > "If we start building significantly more nuclear capacity," Why do you think that's going to happen, when nuclear is so grossly uncompetitive? And if cheap uranium is running out, then nuclear is in even worse trouble. Reprocessing might make it not quite as bad for nuclear, but the net effect would still be to place another economic hurdle in the way of fission.