3 ms·
IMHO: No. Way more important would be a high-speed BART for the Bay area, and an equivalent for LA. Most people would benefit from it; instead, an SF-LA high-sp
by simonebrunozzi 8y ago
IMHO: No. Way more important would be a high-speed BART for the Bay area, and an equivalent for LA. Most people would benefit from it; instead, an SF-LA high-speed with slow "local" public transport would only benefit a few.
- hedora 8y agoThe Bay Area already has enough train routes to create a viable commuter system, but they are not connected, or even time synchronized. Some are idle, or prioritize freight over commuters. The systems include (counter clockwise from east bay): Bart, Amtrak Capitol Corridor, ACE, VTA, the old valley <-> Santa Cruz line, Caltrain, and Muni. The only part missing commuter rail stops is Marin county, and they have a nice ferry to SF (they intentionally blocked BART).
- m_mueller 8y agoBART is also ridiculously slow. To compare, within the similarly dense and similarly sized Swiss middlelands I can hop on the train system and compete with cars going highway speeds while reading HN or do whatever. In the Bay area I felt like I had to plan half a day to get into SF one way alone. There's no reason why you can't have at least Swiss quality rail there, not even talking about Japanese levels.
- djrogers 8y agoI'm not sure what day you tried to take BART, but getting to SF from the far end of a line takes about an hour or less. Oh, and there are several stretches of that where the train will run at 70MPH - freeway speeds. Sure, it could be faster (and quieter, and more comfortable) but it's not slow.
- m_mueller 8y agoI went from San Jose to SF which is about 1h 35min for a distance that's slightly less than Basel to Zurich, once you get there. There's two major factors that make it slow for me: One, American trainstations are often far away from town centers. Two, BART stops everywhere even though it's quite a sizeable distance. For these distances we'd typically have an interregional connection that only stops 3-4 times. Basel Zürich takes about 55min btw. and you arrive right in each city's center, with tons of public transport to connect you further. SF main station by comparison looked tiny to me, with less connections than lots of Swiss towns with maybe 200k inhabitants have. And I'm not even talking about HSR, for that have a look at Paris to Lyon or Tokyo to Osaka for some example.
- masonic 8y agoBut BART isn't high speed rail at all. It's basically a 50 year old design infrastructure.