3 ms·
I think there are some things you could do to receive better responses to your comments in the future. First of all, there's a reason the HN guidelines explici
by yorwba 8y ago
I think there are some things you could do to receive better responses to your comments in the future.
First of all, there's a reason the HN guidelines explicitly prohibit complaining that someone hasn't read an article. Not everyone has the same background knowledge, so even if they read the article, they may not have paid attention to the same details, failing to realize their significance. If you think some part is relevant to a point you want to make, just refer to it, e.g. "The article mentions that..."
Second, the same differences in background knowledge also mean that not everyone will draw the same conclusions from the same facts. If you think you know something that contradicts or enhances the comment you're replying to, you'll be understood more easily if you explicitly state which part you're referring to. E.g. when you bring up the unequal treaties, it is unclear why you think that someone who knows about them would not write a comment like m0zg's.
Third, as HN is a community built around intellectual curiosity, a good comment usually contains some novel information. This very comment of yours I'm replying to contains none.
Fourth, while letting off some steam by accusing others of bad behavior can make you feel better, it's not really interesting for other commenters, so you could just as well not respond at all. I happen to agree that US colonial history is irrelevant in the context of this discussion, but saying so is equally irrelevant.
Fifth, my comment is of course also totally irrelevant. Feel free to ignore it if you don't find it helpful.
- NotPaidToPost 8y agoThere is a difference between different opinions and idiotic replies that are tantamount to trolling. I am fine with the former but not the latter, which is at best noise but usually simply poisons any thoughtful discussion as we see here: My comments were hijacked and poisoned.
- kolanos 8y agoObviously the poster you initially replied to was trolling. My posts on the other hand were trying to highlight what I believe to be obvious historical parallels. If you still believe that to be "irrelevant", you certainly haven't made a case one way or the other. I'm going to move on, but try not to lump everyone into the troll bucket next time?