3 ms·
Good. It was a huge waste of money anyway. It was being built in the wrong order (why would you build the parts that would get the least ridership first?!), i
by jedberg 8y ago
Good. It was a huge waste of money anyway. It was being built in the wrong order (why would you build the parts that would get the least ridership first?!), it was going to the wrong places, and at the end of the day, it would not have helped the poor communities between SF and LA.
We have hundreds of flights a day between SF and LA. We don't need a train to replace that.
- martinald 8y agoIt was built in the "wrong order" because the areas near cities had existing commuter rail, and therefore weren't eligible for federal "new start" grants. Of course, FAA grant money is available to expand SFO, OAK and LAX... no questions asked.
- asdff 8y agoBecause airlines have a ticker and a public train does not, unfortunately.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It was being built in the wrong order (why would you build the parts that would get the least ridership first?!) Because the initial operating segment needed to be near one of the endpoints (San Jose to Bakersfield was the plan) in order to maximize ridership, meaning the initial construction segment should be, at least largely, part of such a segment (the ICS was Bakersfield to Merced), and the ICS was specifically select because of relative ease of construction and federal funding being available for work that could start relatively soon at the time with a priority to economically hard hit areas for economic development purposes, which the valley end of the planned IOS fit. > at the end of the day, it would not have helped the poor communities between SF and LA. Yes, it would have. > We have hundreds of flights a day between SF and LA. We don't need a train to replace that. The economic case for the train was made on the bases of expected displaced road traffic and reduced funds dedicated to highway construction and maintenance with it versus without it, not replacing air travel.
- masonic 8y agoThe economic case for the train was made on the bases of expected displaced road traffic It wouldn't have disrupted freight traffic at all, which is the lion's share
- briandear 8y ago> it would not have helped the poor communities between SF and LA. Just curious, but how does a high speed train help the poor? A local train maybe, but not too many poor people have a pressing need for a weekend in San Francisco.