4 ms·
My theory is that prison is only effective on people that are already fairly morally grounded and with pretty healthy social and mental dynamics. So those folks
by chrisco255 8y ago
My theory is that prison is only effective on people that are already fairly morally grounded and with pretty healthy social and mental dynamics. So those folks can and do bounce back.
But prison does nothing to help with mental illness or help give folks a sense of community once they're out.
- PorterDuff 8y agoThey may have a sense of community, it just might be one that is harmful to your own. My own theory is that prison has been set up to remove potential criminals from the street, chosen via a demographic of education/ethnicity/wealth/gender/aggressiveness, during their prime years of being a nuisance. The results don't have to be particularly fair. There's no real intention of transformation or revenge, just a form of quarantine. Looking at a chart of incarceration rate over time and murder rate over time, this last a better indicator of crime than most, you can make a case that the big ramp up in jailing somewhat matches the peak and fall of murders. It's tough to find causalities in anything, but I rather like that one.
- csin 8y agoI wonder if you'll be singing a different tune, if you were born black...
- PorterDuff 8y agoWhat tune? I'm just giving a theory of why things have evolved the way they have.
- rexpop 8y ago> potential criminals This is a self-referential definition. The removal of vibrant individuals from such communities is design to crippled them, making them more reliant on, e.g. unfavorable employment.
- rayiner 8y agoWho is a “vibrant individual.”
- fzeroracer 8y agoWe could just start by addressing the elephant in the room which is that black people are disproportionately arrested for marijuana despite using drugs at the same rate as white people [1]. Which, naturally, can cripple families for incredibly small amounts of possession. [1] https://www.splcenter.org/20180918/racial-profiling-louisiana-unconstitutional-and-counterproductive https://www.splcenter.org/20180918/racial-profiling-louisian...
- rayiner 8y agoI’m literally just asking what the term “vibrant individual” means.
- PorterDuff 8y agoI thought that I sort of implied that in the root post, although I expect that there's more to it than your example. It's easy these days to get arrested for minor deviltries (way easier than when I was a lad) so the police have that in their pocket. So, you pick out the groups who are statistically most likely to commit real crimes, pick them up for any old thing, and warehouse them until they are more old and tired. Like I said, it's not fair, but it appears to work to some extent.
- fromthestart 8y ago>despite using drugs at the same rate as white people This statistic does not accommodate for cultural differences in use. It's quite possible that black people are more likely to carry and/or use marijuana in public or while driving.
- rexpop 8y agoEvery living being. The point is that criminalization of poverty drains vitality from already-marginalized communities.
- im3w1l 8y agoWouldn't surprise me if law abiding black people are the biggest beneficiaries of the way the system works. Imagine living in the ghetto if there was no policing.
- crooked-v 8y ago> Imagine living in the ghetto if there was no policing. There would be plenty of problems, but not being stopped and frisked constantly because of skin tone even though white people are more likely per capita to actually be a valid target of the frisking[1] would probably be nice. [1]: https://www.nyclu.org/en/stop-and-frisk-data https://www.nyclu.org/en/stop-and-frisk-data https://www.nyclu.org/sites/default/files/field_documents/20190314_nyclu_stopfrisk_singles.pdf https://www.nyclu.org/sites/default/files/field_documents/20... ("Black and Latino people were more likely to be frisked than whites and, among those frisked, were less likely to be found with a weapon.")
- closeparen 8y agoPrisoners by and large do not become productive members of society, nor do they fear prison enough to avoid recidivism. But they almost never escape, and the handful of escapes this century were all captured or killed within weeks. Quarantine is, if not what it’s it aimed at, what it accomplishes in practice.
- lkrubner 8y agoWhat universe do you live in? 96% of all prisoners are released. Less than 4% serve life sentences. The reason why rehabilitation needs to be emphasized is because we live with large numbers of ex-criminals. They serve their time and they are released and now they are part of our society again.
- closeparen 8y agoThe one where 76% reoffend within 5 years [0]. Whatever its stated goals or values, rehabilitation is not an actual effect of the penal system. [0] https://www.nij.gov/topics/corrections/recidivism/pages/welcome.aspx https://www.nij.gov/topics/corrections/recidivism/pages/welc...
- stcredzero 8y agoThey may have a sense of community, it just might be one that is harmful to your own. By some accounts, prison is an opportunity to network and gain mentors and knowledge towards furthering a career as a criminal. There's no real intention of transformation or revenge, just a form of quarantine. If considered as a criminal networking opportunity, it's likely to transform people into those who would seek revenge, and it would have the opposite effect intended by quarantine. EDIT: I'm reminded of a folk dance group I was once a part of. Usually, we were obscure, and the one or two new people who might show up would become immersed in what we did, and would quickly learn to dance. Once, there was a local newspaper article about us, and 16 newcomers showed up all at once. It was very difficult that evening, and I think a lot of the newcomers didn't learn much. If we want incarceration to make people less criminal, not more criminal, then the prisoners should not be spending their time with criminals. The prisoners should be spending their time with mentors, teachers, and counselors.
- crooked-v 8y ago> If we want incarceration to make people less criminal, not more criminal, then the prisoners should not be spending their time with criminals. The prisoners should be spending their time with mentors, teachers, and counselors. I immediately think of Nordic prison systems, where even the highest-security prisons are usually set up as an idealized microcosm of the outside world, with real living spaces, personal prisoner responsibility for preparing meals and cleaning up, grocery shopping and money management, workshops and classes, jobs that are designed for real vocational training, etc [1]. The recidivism rates are around 20% (some of the lowest in the world), with specific prisons approaching 15%. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/feb/25/norwegian-prison-inmates-treated-like-people https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/feb/25/norwegian-pr...
- PorterDuff 8y agoBy 'revenge' I'm referring to revenge by society by putting people in an unpleasant situation for a term.
- stcredzero 8y ago
- crooked-v 8y ago"Potential criminal" is a term so vague as to be useless, because its boundaries are overwhelming shaped to oppress minorities and the poor. Consider criminalization of loitering and its effects on poor people, criminalization of "gang association" (even when in practice it can mean "cousin of a gang member" or "babysat the child of a gang member's sister"), and the soft-touch handling of Oxycontin addicts while crack cocaine users get life in prison.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoOnly... other countries have different systems with different outcomes. They treat mental illness, have safety nets, and don't push folks out of prison as ill-equipped to deal with the world. We (Americans) can do better. Fewer people in prison, focusing on reintegration into society, proper facilities and health care (including mental health). And so on. But we (Americans) aren't willing to do these things, even if it is cheaper overall and has better outcomes for both the inmates and their families. A politician will claim these policies are "soft on crime" and putting rapists on the streets and that these people should pay dearly for whatever crimes they've done and they get votes.
- rayiner 8y agoI question whether we can do better. I don’t think pointing to other countries is helpful. The murder rate in the US was 10x higher than in the U.K. even at the turn of the 20th century. Long before ideas of prison as a place for rehabilitation, which came about in the 1950s and 1960s. It’s important to remember that American incarceration is a lagging trend, not a leading trend. Incarceration rates were flat for a long time before trending up in the 1970s. That followed about a decade behind a long period of increase in crime that started in the 1960s and lasted through the 1990s.
- lkrubner 8y agoIn 1900 the northern USA states had a murder rate that was the same as most European countries. The elevated murder rate in the USA came entirely from the sky high murder rates in the ex slave states.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoIt's a big order: We'd honestly have to put an actual safety net in for everyone for it to work well, but we can start by treating people like humans, having safe prison environments, and making sure folks have a chance. Change laws so the stupid thing one did at 19 doesn't have lasting effects at 24. Make sure parole officers have flexible hours that allow folks to have jobs. No one should have to commit crimes to pay their fees. It isn't worth looking at the crime rates, as we've never tried. Crime rates are more than just prison, but the right prison system is one avenue to reduce repeat crimes.
- swgdo 8y agoSo what you're basically saying is that some people should simply rot in prison because they're too dangerous to society? Well, I agree with you. Just not politically correct these days...
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThere might be some potential debate about which people are genuinely most dangerous.
- idrios 8y agoAs someone who has never been to prison and not worked in any part of the legal system, my opinion holds limited weight. But I believe prisons were originally designed to act as dissuasion against bad behavior from regular folk, and a form of quarantine for more violent or harmful people. I think they've since turned into some horrible form of daycare for adults who don't know how to be adults, and which makes no effort to improve the lives of inmates because it has no incentive to. Meaningful jobs have diminished to the point that someone who didn't make it through high school will have an extremely difficult time finding success in life (and those who did will boast so loudly about it that you'd think anyone could do it). Entire communities in low-income neighborhoods have developed where people have no idea what to do with their lives. I think a lot of other-wise decent and well-meaning individuals get arrested for stealing or public intoxication or whatnot because they have no idea what they should be doing with their time. One story that has stuck out to me over the years is that of a kid who was a hero in 2013 for rescuing a young girl, and by 2016 he was sentenced to prison for armed robbery [1]. Prisons themselves don't get any funding if nobody's going to prison, so they have a perverse incentive where they want people to go to jail. [1] https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/temar-boggs-hero-teen-rescued-girl-sentenced-robbery-article-1.2760740 https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/temar-boggs-hero-t...