3 ms·
The part I find most interesting is about the strength of Xi's grip on China. Either Xi has rejected this (at least for the moment), and has directed his puppe
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
The part I find most interesting is about the strength of Xi's grip on China.
Either Xi has rejected this (at least for the moment), and has directed his puppets to "reject" it (to give the appearance of them stopping him from doing something he was reluctantly willing to do)...
Or Xi is not as firmly in total control of China as various events had led me to believe.
His thought is enshrined in the constitution. He's breaking precedent by remaining in charge for life, not just for ten years. But he can't approve a trade deal if others don't like it? Is this "you can be dictator as much as you please, but mess up the economy and you're gone"?
I also find it telling that "you can't keep taking our IP just because we're doing business" is termed "unequal". Interesting idea of "equality" there...
- Leary 8y agoMost important decisions require the approval of the 7 men Standing Committee of the Politburo[1], of which Xi is only one member. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politburo_Standing_Committee_of_the_Communist_Party_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politburo_Standing_Committee_o...
- thebooktocome 8y agoXi has enormous amounts of soft power with which to influence the Standing Committee.
- pinkfoot 8y agoYou will then be horrified to learn that US intelligence has a written mandate to obtain foreign technology that the US lacks and make it available to US industry. A well-kept little dirty secret.
- chibg10 8y agoSource?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoClassic what-about-ism. And I deeply resent you putting words in my mouth (or at least attitudes in my brain). It's a dishonest, cheap rhetorical trick. And apparently you can't see the difference between the government trying to take it by spying, and the government forcing you to give it away by contract as a condition of doing business. Hint: One you can take countermeasures against; one you can't. And, like others, I would like to see your source.
- dang 8y agoPlease keep the whataboutism cliché off HN (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19862258 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19862258 for more). Also, please keep deep resentment off HN. If that's how you're feeling, find some other way to process it before returning to comment here. (Edit: I know that's not easy, but it's necessary for this place to not burn.)
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoWhat I'm trying to fight is this trope: "If you are in favor of A, then you must also favor X", where X is something almost-but-not-quite-completely different from A. (That's why I picked X instead of B.) And that's usually the end of the comment. There's no explanation of why X and A are like each other in any way that matters. There's no conclusion, like either "Since I presume you're not in favor of X, you can't consistently be in favor of A either", or the opposite, "Since you're in favor of A, you really ought to reconsider your position on X". What there is, though, is what feels to me like an attempt to put words in the other person's mouth. This feels to me like a step beyond whataboutism. It's not just "what about X", it's "You must also agree that X is true". I've been seeing this pattern increasingly over the last 6 to 12 months. (Alternately, I've become more sensitive to this pattern in the same time.) I consider it to be... let's just say it's not a positive contribution to the discussion. So: How should one respond to this? Flag every instance? Ignore? Simply respond "Non sequitur" and leave it at that? You don't like how I responded. Fine; you have the right. But what do you think I should do instead?
- 8y ago
- pasabagi 8y agoI think this is actually rather typical of dictatorships - the more 'absolute' the power of the leader, the less dispersed sovereignty is, the more they end up having to go with the current. There are two standard reasons for this. First, when you have a coalition, even in a non-democratic state, and the coalition agrees to do something, you're pretty safe - because you have everybody who matters on board. Second, people often end up in the position of absolute tough-man dictator because, unfortunately, that's what a lot of people want from their leaders. So it's often the case that the strongman stuff follows from a relatively weak grasp on power, rather than the other way around, as the leaders are pushed to play the part the audience wants from them (pre-WW2 Japan has been said to have been like this). PS: This is actually the classic Roman formula. The Emperor uses the support of the mob (soldiers, citizens, etc) to counterbalance against the traditional nobility (senate). So you get guys who technically are the absolute ruler and god of the state, bending over backwards to keep public opinion sweet.
- chewz 8y agoParty beauracracy runs China not Comrade Eleven. Have no doubts that Xi will be dealt with if he does not obey. This is how most autocracies work internaly. The ruler is only as powerful as tangled web of intrests and loyalties that keeps him in power. So he must accomodate his partners. > This is not a personally run empire but a huge and difficult-to-manage bureaucratic machine with its own internal rules and principles,” “It happens time and again that the president says something, and then nothing or the opposite happens.” [1] [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/23/sunday-review/how-powerful-is-vladimir-putin-really.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/23/sunday-review/how-powerfu...