5 ms·
I think what people choose to eat is extremely personal to them. I'm glad you made a lifestyle choice that benefitted you, but I would shudder the thought of li
by chrisco255 8y ago
I think what people choose to eat is extremely personal to them. I'm glad you made a lifestyle choice that benefitted you, but I would shudder the thought of living in a society where the government tells you exactly what you can and can't eat.
Education, public awareness, these kind of initiatives I can get behind. Regulation of food intake, is a step too far.
FWIW, I've eaten processed, fried, GMO foods my whole life (and consume fast food drive thru at least 5-6 times a week) and have no health issues whatsoever. But I try to not eat to excess and I exercise regularly.
- moorhosj 8y agoDon’t we already regulate what can be put in foods via the FDA?
- homonculus1 8y ago"Don't we already" is an excuse, not an argument.
- moorhosj 8y agoThere were food and drug products that were unsafe, “adulterated” and mislabeled. This created health problems in the United States so we created the FDA to regulate food and drugs. Do you have any argument why they shouldn’t do this?
- homonculus1 8y agoToxicity and fraudulent misadvertisement is a far cry from sugar being bad for you if you choose to eat too much of it. And to reiterate my point, advocating X based on "don't we already Y" instead of the actual merits of X is a big part of how dangerous slippery slopes occur, even if Y was a good thing.
- moorhosj 7y agoIn this case, the poster said: "Education, public awareness, these kind of initiatives I can get behind. Regulation of food intake, is a step too far." I merely pointed out that the thing identified as "a step too far" already exists. I wasn't advocating for anything so there isn't a slippery slope to fear.
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoProve it, post a picture of yourself without a shirt on and tell us how old you are.
- ieie92ndjrj 8y agoYou might be surprised to learn the government does “tell us” what we can eat by defining what can be sold. Thanks for keeping us safe from government boogeymen though
- EpicEng 8y agoI doubt the GP is unaware of food regulations. Like pretty much everything else in life, what matters is degree and nuance. The government saying that e.g. milk must meet a minimum level of XYZ is not the same as the government telling us that we can no longer drink milk at all.
- jniedrauer 8y agoWe already regulate dangerous, addictive products like cigarettes. Why not regulate dangerous, addictive products like potato chips or soft drinks?
- nsxwolf 8y agoMy body, my choice? Or is that only for some things?
- ieie92ndjrj 8y agoBut that’s the point: your choices are food products that are allowed under regulations. People are dragging out this paranoid fantasy where Uncle Sam is literally spoon feeding you. When tacitly he’s enabling you to spoon feed yourself his choices. People seem really convinced the next step is a government assigned personal health manager.
- chrisco255 8y agoWe don't really regulate the number of cigs that someone can smoke a day.
- ieie92ndjrj 8y agoTrying to understand how they got onto the government forcing us to eat a specific set of foods from the original comment which to my read was about food regulations (the food supply chain being a byproduct of those). I mean just cause you CAN view it from the perspective of concern that some G-man will show up every morning to check your pantry doesn’t mean one is on topic, or peddling reasonable discourse. Yes, be on the lookout for government overreach. Sure. Immediately invoking paranoid nonsense and individualism (which ends being heavily constrained by social norms anyway) is just bizarre
- kennywinker 8y agoEducation, as you suggest only works for some percentage of the population who have the time and wealth to learn what is good for their body and pay for it. Without government regulation you’re basically abandoning some percentage of the population to eat whatever crap has the lowest price and highest margins. We already accept and benefit from regulation on what can be put in food - insect parts, inorganic additives, etc. - but those regulations have not kept up with advances in food tech.
- nokcha 8y ago>but I would shudder the thought of living in a society where the government tells you exactly what you can and can't eat. I agree, but the government can use softer nudges like taxes and subsidies to help encourage healthier eating. A good start would be to examine existing farm subsidies and ask whether they encourage unhealthy dietary choices.
- billmalarky 8y ago>I think what people choose to eat is extremely personal to them. I'm glad you made a lifestyle choice that benefitted you, but I would shudder the thought of living in a society where the government tells you exactly what you can and can't eat. This canned "the government shouldn't choose what I eat" argument is reductionist to the point of deficiency at best, and disingenuous at worse. The fact is an unregulated free market forces choices on us no different than government regulation. The quality and type of food a consumer has access to is highly dependent on market decisions — that is the food demanded by other consumers — not individual decisions. The problem is consumers in the US at large are either ignorant about health/nutrition or just plain don't prioritize the future (sustainable health) over the present (what I'm eating was iteratively designed in a lab to maximize my immediate dopamine hit). Good regulation isn't binary. You can regulate the food industry to protect consumers from predatory/harmful practices (such as engineering food so that consumers overeat by "growth hacking" food via salt/sugar/fat in order to drive revenue growth) while still allowing an abundance of dietary choices. >FWIW, I've eaten processed, fried, GMO foods my whole life (and consume fast food drive thru at least 5-6 times a week) and have no health issues whatsoever. But I try to not eat to excess and I exercise regularly. Some people smoke two packs a day and die at the ripe old age of 100. The vast majority of smokers die significantly earlier than average. Much like you wouldn't consider a lottery ticket a wise investment even if it pays off, you shouldn't interpret your personal health and dietary experience to much other than good fortune. Your experience is an outlier in the face of mountains of data that tell a different and honestly quite depressing story. Lastly, I know sometimes tone can be misinterpreted easily in text. So if my comment came off as brash or an attack etc, please re-read it with a polite and friendly tone in mind. I'm passionate about this topic because I want to help.
- chrisco255 8y agoDon't equivocate eating food to smoking. There is no evidence that someone who consumes a healthy level of calories (whether those calories are wheat-based, meat-based, potato-based, etc) are putting themselves on any kind of path to cancer or heart disease. Carbs are carbs. Protein is protein. Fat is fat. Sure, some types of foods (including fried foods) have excessive calories for the average American lifestyle. That's been known for decades. But there is no evidence that calories from broccoli are any less or more cancerous than calories from potatoes or bread or vegetable oil. My experience is not an outlier. This guy has eaten 30,000 Big Macs, perfectly healthy: https://people.com/food/mcdonalds-big-mac-supersize-me-don-gorske-world-record/ https://people.com/food/mcdonalds-big-mac-supersize-me-don-g... Studies on diets with a variety of macros (but the same calories): https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19246357 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19246357 CONCLUSIONS: Reduced-calorie diets result in clinically meaningful weight loss regardless of which macronutrients they emphasize. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17413101 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17413101 CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide more detailed evidence to suggest that diets differing substantially in glycemic load induce comparable long-term weight loss.
- not_a_moth 8y ago> consume fast food drive thru at least 5-6 times a week > have no health issues whatsoever That you're aware of. What's your fasted glucose level, or A1c? What about inflammation markers? Given your lifestyle you should probably know your calcium score (heart) too. You could be pre-diabetic and not even know it, which means without intervention, you'll be really screwed in your not so distant future. You might already have plaque and scars accumulating in your heart. Or elevated inflammation slowly damaging organs in your body. Know your numbers if you're going to eat fast food every day of the week.
- gambler 8y ago>You could be pre-diabetic and not even know it That can be said about anyone.
- not_a_moth 8y ago"pre diabetic" is a clinical designation. You can be or not be it, and know it, with blood tests.