4 ms·
I was thinking about the solar panel example, I think that in this case the US (and Germany, another country that has made similar complaints) can instead focus
by paganel 8y ago
I was thinking about the solar panel example, I think that in this case the US (and Germany, another country that has made similar complaints) can instead focus their economic resources on trying to solve energy storage and distribution, which is still an unsolved problem (I mean “unsolved” in the context of the intermittent power inputs provided by solar and wind) and they can use part of the money that would have otherwise been spent on building solar panels (remember, these are now subsidized by the Chinese) on trying to achieve this.
- mistermann 8y agoThey can do this, but I think the point of contention is whether it will ultimately turn out to be a wise strategic decision. The fact that it's not an entirely voluntary decision also seems at least somewhat important.
- paganel 8y agoRegular people take economic steps because of decisions almost forced on them from the outside on a regular basis, being stubborn about going down a route that is not economically rational anymore it's just that, stubbornness. I remember our 60-year old mom being discontent about my brother still wanting to be in the business of selling cows (my brother was a peasant) even though that wasn't economically rational anymore, as my brother had to fight against agri-business (he's a sole cow breeder) and against farmers from other countries whose governments are more generous towards them (our government it's not that large-handed when it comes to small farmers, I live in Eastern Europe). My mother correctly pointed out that there was a lot more money available for my brother if he had only wanted to accept other job opportunities (like being a truck driver) and give up what was essentially an economically dead end. So, if a 60-year old woman from Eastern Europe with no formal education in economics can still intuitively see what the best economically rational move is given a set of inputs, then I fail to understand how come a democratically elected government like the US one cannot do the same, but instead it chooses to go down the economically dead end road, and all that only because of stubbornness and misguided pride.
- mistermann 8y ago> Regular people take economic steps because of decisions almost forced on them from the outside on a regular basis, being stubborn about going down a route that is not economically rational anymore it's just that, stubbornness. While this may be true for individuals, it seems perfectly reasonable that it could also be due to things like poor strategic planning, poor salary/trade negotiation, an unnecessary willingness to roll over when resistance is encountered, etc. The #1 economic and military superpower of the world has vastly more resources and options at its disposal than an individual farmer. > but instead it chooses to go down the economically dead end road Just to be clear....you are claiming that you can "intuitively see" that this economic road is certain to be an economic "dead end" (I'm not sure of the exact meaning of that in an economic context)? And you can also "see" that the motives of those who disagree with you are limited only to stubbornness and misguided pride?