3 ms·
Not sure why FUD like this keeps popping up every time a tech company workforce wants to unionize. There are many different types of unions. The types of union
by gamblor956 8y ago
Not sure why FUD like this keeps popping up every time a tech company workforce wants to unionize.
There are many different types of unions. The types of unions that organize low-wage workers aren't the same unions that organize high-wage workers or workers in talent-based fields like Hollywood, music, etc.
Workers choose what they want the union to be, and how it is organized, as part of unionizing.
- TAForObvReasons 8y ago> Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires. s/Socialism/Unions/; s/America/Tech/; s/poor/workers/; s/millionaires/billionaire founders/
- CryptoPunk 8y agoUnions did take root in America. For a time all major industrial sectors were dominated by unions. It resulted in America losing its manufacturing edge and seeing most manufacturing migrate to Asia. The entire passenger rail service also went bankrupt due to the demands of the Brotherhoods, which had a stranglehold on the industry. Today, besides a few notable exceptions like Hollywood and the screen actors guild, unions are only growing in the public sector, and that's because taxpayers are forced to subsidize their inefficiency. Also, socialism did take root in America. Look at the percentage of GDP consumed by government spending since 1900. It's steadily grown, especially on social welfare programs. America paid a very heavy price to gain real world experience with unions/socialism. Let's hope that after paying the price from that century-long mistake, it learns a lesson.
- gamblor956 8y agoInterestingly enough, America's manufacturing prowress also coincided with the prowress of unions. It was the rise of the executive class that doomed both America's manufacturing and its unions. It turns out that when the people who don't actually make anything have total leverage, they do a good job of fucking everything up. The entire passenger rail service also went bankrupt due to the demands of the Brotherhoods, which had a stranglehold on the industry. This is simply false. Passenger rail service went bankrupt as a result of many forces, including the rise of the automobile and the dominance of the cargo transport industry in America, which owns almost all of the rail lines in the US and prioritizes freight shipping over passenger conveyance.
- masonic 8y agoAmerica's manufacturing prowress also coincided with the prowress of unions. It coincided with World War II and its aftermath. You're confusing cause with effect. And I think the word you want is "prowess".
- CryptoPunk 8y agoNo, American manufacturing started losing its competitive edge in the heydey of unions. It is only because American manufacturing saw a market decline that union membership rates in the private sector declined. When US manufacturing was expanding the fastest was when unions had no power, in the late 19th century, and that was also when wages were increasing at their fastest rate. Unlike the post-war wage growth, the wage growth of the late 19th century did not come at the expense of the industry that was providing those wages. >>This is simply false. Passenger rail service went bankrupt as a result of many forces You should read up on the agreement that the brotherhoods forced on the passenger rail lines and what that did to their financial position. The growing power of the brotherhoods is primarily what did the rail lines in.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoAny time someone criticizes unions, these conspiracy theories pop up. No one is spreading FUD. They're relaying their experiences with unions, which in no way contradicts your statement that there are many types of unions.
- duxup 8y agoAs someone with experience the idea that the workers choose is a bit laughable. Once established the union is largely inflexible and not likely or able renegotiate the structure... that is just how it works historically. Folks mentioning it isn't just FUD because you don't agree, for some of us it's experience.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- moate 8y agoOut of curiosity, what sector are you talking about? Not generally, but your specific experience?
- gamblor956 8y agoI've been on both sides of the table for multiple union negotiations, including several unsuccessful ones that failed due to management interference. Some of the unions were for low-skilled laborers. Others were for highly-skilled talent-based workers. And two were government unions. Each union was differently organized to meet the needs of its specific set of workers. You can't make blanket statements like "once a union is established its largely inflexible" since the history of American unions is expressly opposite of that statement. Every major union has undergone massive structural changes multiple times. Unions have merged, split up, merged again, died, resurrected, etc. A history of American unions would be as complex as Game of Thrones, with even more violence and only a bit less sex.