7 ms·
I was watching a sitcom called Superstore a little while ago, features the employees in a Wal-Mart like store, and the protagonist got a promotion to the head o
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
I was watching a sitcom called Superstore a little while ago, features the employees in a Wal-Mart like store, and the protagonist got a promotion to the head of the store. There was a whole plot line about how her wage was now in the 6 figures, and I was incredulous until I did a bit of research - Wal-Mart store managers can absolutely make that much money while their employees live in poverty.
How you could make that much and expect loyalty and sacrifice from your staff who make a fraction of that, I won't ever know.
- 14 8y agoI am guessing they don’t expect loyalty but rather desperation and the need to pay bills. Use the person until they move on and get a new one. I make about 9$ an hour above minimum wage and I can not even fathom how a person on minimum wage survives.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoThat may be the pragmatic assumption, but I've worked my fair share of low paying jobs, and there's a ton of talk of being part of the team.
- c0vfefe 8y agoThere's a difference between what leadership will say publicly & what they really mean. Reading between the lines of retail manager's inspiring speeches will reveal that their personal careers are directly affected by the store's bottom line, and they're certainly not going to explicitly acknowledge their employees' desperation as a motivational tool.
- ap3 8y agoWhy do you think anyone expects “loyalty and sacrifice” for minimum wage at Walmart! sacrifice? c’mon
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoThey will always ask you to work harder, put on more responsibilities, maybe stay a little late after you clock out to tidy up, always.
- zaroth 8y agoYou’re fine up until that labor violation at the end there. The state will quickly fine them for that, and any manager worth $100k knows better than to ask it.
- blacktonystark 8y agoWell, most managers at any pay scale definitely act like they don't know better.
- ensignavenger 8y agoWalmarts min pay is a lot higher than min wage in most states.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoSupposes employer A chooses to pay their employees more than other employers. Employer B chooses to pay their employees less. Both employers are selling products or services that the purchaser finds the same, i.e. they have no preference for who they buy it from. Employer B takes the money they save by paying employees less, and invests in newer, better facilities or R&D or whatever. Now employer B is selling a better product than employer A. Who will customers choose to purchase from? Who will lose business, and end up having to fire employees? To be a successful business, compensation decisions can't be based on people's feelings. You have to consider when a new store or hotel or restaurant will come around and put them out of business, and stay ahead of the curve. You pay what you need to to get the job done. There are some good examples like Costco, but there are only so many people with sufficient disposable income who can afford to shop at Costco and similar stores, and they're not competing with Walmart/CVS/Dollar Store or other bottom tier vendors.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoBut employer B also can now remove employees due to the investments they made in automation - if they can remove the workers entirely they'll have even more money to invest in making a better product to edge out employer A. At the end of the day the worker always loses.
- c0vfefe 8y ago> At the end of the day the worker always loses. Rise up comrades, and shake off the bourgeoisie! /s
- close04 8y agoThat’s a bit oversimplified. Automation doesn’t fix everything, it may not be a useful option regardless of how much money you just saved. It’s more likely the best employees will move towards the company that pays more, along with their experience and know how, probably producing a better product. On one side you’ll have the best people and on the other side you’ll have ones that may be good but also very upset about the disparity. I would still question if saving on personnel brings the most benefit in most cases. It’s short term benefit, enough for an executive to get the bonus. It may also be long term if everyone is doing it so an employee has no option.
- beat 8y agoEconomics is amoral. It doesn't know good from evil. The biggest mistake on the right is thinking that capitalism is Good. The biggest mistake on the left is thinking that capitalism is Evil. It just is. It's like thermodynamics. If you get burned by a hot stove, it doesn't mean physics is evil. And it doesn't mean getting burned is just your imagination, either. Without intelligence guiding them, such systems can easily destroy themselves with feedback loops. Power differentials etc, in an amoral environment, lead to low-level employees getting screwed and owners/upper management getting rich. This feedback loop can eventually destroy a company, or a society. So what I find hard to understand isn't that employees go along with this system that screws them (they need to eat, y'know?), but rather that they think it's good, that it's what's best for everyone, that maximized profits will be equitably distributed. We have an angry, populist working class that has completely accepted the systematic inequalities of neoliberal-flavored capitalism, and the socialist welfare-state hacks that come with it mostly to keep the whole thing from self-destructing this year at least. They're mad they're getting screwed, but think their bosses are completely right to screw them. It's really hard to grok that.
- conanbatt 8y ago> Economics is amoral Such a thing does not exist. It is the study of exchange between individuals, any model that brings down morality to 0 will not be useful, practical or a applicable. There is a reason why the most iconic political economists were all philosophers!
- beat 8y agoWhen you buy something from Amazon, is it an exchange between individuals? When you get a paycheck from a corporate employer, is it an exchange between individuals? No, that makes no sense. It's an exchange between an individual and an abstract legal/financial entity that engages in economic activity, but is in no rational way a human being. And what about B2B exchange? Clearly, it's economics, but when Wal-Mart buys a wholesale lot of shampoo from Proctor & Gamble, it is absurd to think of that as "between individuals".
- 8y ago
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> There was a whole plot line about how her wage was now in the 6 figures, and I was incredulous until I did a bit of research - Wal-Mart store managers can absolutely make that much money while their employees live in poverty. The problem is fundamentally this: A typical Wal-Mart store has around 300 employees. If you take the manager's entire $100,000 and distribute it to the employees, they each get less than $500/year, a raise of less than $0.25/hour. Meanwhile you're never going to get a good manager for the price of a stock clerk, because it's skilled vs. unskilled labor. But you still need a manager. And nice as it would be to pay all 300 employees $100K/year, that would immediately bankrupt the store. Moreover, it would be more than the amount it would cost to automate most of those jobs. This is not a problem with glib or moralistic solutions. And the solutions that do exist are probably more along the lines of making housing cost less so lower income people can afford it, rather than chastising the employers who actually employ unskilled workers.
- mgkimsal 8y ago> And nice as it would be to pay all 300 employees $100K/year, that would immediately bankrupt the store I don't think everyone necessarily expects $100k/employee. But many (most?) of them work for 30-35 hours per week - not out of choice, but because their schedule is controlled by the management. And they've generally been paid at or under $10/h. In the last few years there's been moves to increase that, but even moving from full time (which not everyone gets) at $10/hr to, say, $14/hr... That's $28k? Loaded cost with taxes and stuff might be ... $35k? $40k? Maybe? That's still a far cry from "we can't afford to pay everyone $100k". Sure, you can't, but that doesn't explicitly justify paying most people $9/h part time when they want full time (and the store has a need for full time staff, they just don't want to have to provide X benefits that come with full time).
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> In the last few years there's been moves to increase that, but even moving from full time (which not everyone gets) at $10/hr to, say, $14/hr... That's $28k? Loaded cost with taxes and stuff might be ... $35k? $40k? Maybe? That's still a far cry from "we can't afford to pay everyone $100k". Sure, but that's the point. Should the manager not get $100K just because there is no way the employees could? What if that's what it takes to get a good manager? And even at the numbers you're suggesting, multiplied by hundreds of employees, turns into millions of dollars a year. That's more than the store's entire profit. And it's also still above the threshold where it becomes profitable to automate many of those jobs. > Sure, you can't, but that doesn't explicitly justify paying most people $9/h part time when they want full time (and the store has a need for full time staff, they just don't want to have to provide X benefits that come with full time). But whose fault is that? Employers generally shouldn't provide any "benefits" -- they originally came about as a tax dodge at a time when non-monetary benefits weren't considered taxable income to the employee, and that's still the primary reason they exist. Company cars disappeared when they became taxable income, employer-provided health insurance didn't because it's still a tax deduction. But in every case the employees would be better off with the equivalent in cash and the only reason they don't have it is dumb laws. It's even worse for low income employees because the rules keep trying to "help them" by giving employers huge incentives to cut their hours.
- will_brown 8y ago>How you could make that much and expect loyalty and sacrifice from your staff who make a fraction of that, I won't ever know. All those Walmart store managers make 6 figures as you say, some as much as $250k, but the one thing they can always fall back on is they all started out as a low paid Walmart employee as well. It doesn’t change the inequality dynamics but it’s better than something like this story of the healthcare execs making $300k+ bonuses compared to their minimum wage coworkers, where the execs never started out making min wage with the company...or consider the horror story’s of those certain tech companies who don’t even treat low wage employees as regular workers and encourage regular high wage workers not to socialize with the low wage workers.
- ensignavenger 8y agoI didn't know that Walmart store managers were that well paid. And to be certain, they pay a lot more than 7.25/hr to their lowest paid employees!
- mywittyname 8y agoHow much would you expect a person to make who manages and is responsible for the entire operations of a store with revenues in the tens of millions of dollars?
- zaroth 8y agoAnd who perhaps spent 5-10 years learning and developing those skills by rising up the ranks in that company.
- csdreamer7 8y agoI would focus on dividends and executive salaries over store manager's pay. Executives want store managers to be loyal to control theft. Walmart has 2,867,125,000 shares outstanding * $1.96 per quarter * 4 = $22,478,260,000 per year spent on dividends alone. If you take all that money and give it to the 2.1 million employees listed that comes to $10,703 a year in additional wages alone. I haven't even looked at executive salaries or the costs from lawsuits Walmart gets from it's shady tactics. Or that many employees are part time and the per hour wage increase would be much higher than it indicates.