2 ms·
> People just want to have this free will so much that they always intentionally conflate the terms. It's a matter of denotative vs. connotative definitions. F
by naasking 8y ago
> People just want to have this free will so much that they always intentionally conflate the terms.
It's a matter of denotative vs. connotative definitions. Free will proponents are saying, "hey that thing we all do when we make a choice that rocks can't do, that's free will", and you're saying "free will has such and such properties, so whether we have it depends on whether our choices have these properties".
I'd argue that most people reason denotatively, in which case merely pointing out the thing we're trying to define suffices as an existence proof. What remains is defining what it is, logically.
> 1. Determinism or not, free will doesn't exist in either case
It sure does!
> The whole idea of "me" being a singular, well defined thing is purely an artefact of human language. We are a process, not a thing.
Agreed. I don't see why this poses any difficulty. The behaviour of the process is largely governed by free will, just like a process on your computer will often sort lists.
> If free will is so real, can you freely choose never to choose again? Of course not.
Sure, via suicide.
- tpetrina 8y agoSuicide is not the answer to the problem - you need to exist and not decide, not deliberate and not think...or you do accept that some thoughts cannot be _prethought_ by you and they come to you for you to control. So why control _those_ thoughts? Why deliberate in _that particular way_?
- naasking 8y ago> Suicide is not the answer to the problem - you need to exist and not decide It is the answer to the problem as stated. Of course, if you move the goalposts to require two properties that are logically inconsistent, then sure, no conception of free will would qualify. I'm not sure why I should find that compelling. Finally, your focus on "control" is telling of particular assumptions that free will must have certain properties (a connotative definition). Consider whether you are simply mistaken that these properties are necessary. As I said, there is a clear distinction between the behaviour of people and inanimate matter. There is a lot of latitude there for a process that we would recognize as free will.