3 ms·
The legal world works the same way too. They're amazingly low tech. A lawyer in my family mentioned that it's basically a combination of: - everyone can do it
by Waterluvian 8y ago
The legal world works the same way too. They're amazingly low tech. A lawyer in my family mentioned that it's basically a combination of:
- everyone can do it with any software (or even a typewriter)
- consistency with legacy documents. The format doesn't just change on you as you're reading through legal history
- it works fine, why change it?
I'd also add a guess:
- There's no room for implementation detail to affect formatting. Last thing you want is a whole bunch of formats that are similar but not identical, just because someone's software is a bit different.
- could you imagine trying to get everyone to change? We should be so lucky that everyone's already this consistent
- codingdave 8y ago> could you imagine trying to get everyone to change? Yes, this is exactly what I do for a living, consolidating policy and legal documents and their related business workflows into modern applications. My requirements for how the text editors work are far more meticulous than your average app exactly for the reasons you stated. Concerns with formatting that most products would blow off as trivial are deal-breakers in this industry.
- derefr 8y agoIs there a reason to not store the document in an abstract format that is more easily handled by systems useful for legal analysts (e.g. giving you the ability to diff text), and just “renders” to the accepted format? (I’m picturing storing the docs as LaTeX, but anything like that would work. Maybe there could be a legal “theme” for a markdown processor, for example.) Because, in such cases, it wouldn’t really matter if the editor renders the source to text incorrectly, as long as the proofer renders it correctly. Just like with WYSIWYG desktop-publishing software.
- codingdave 8y agoStorage formats aren't the issue. We diff and merge documents just fine, and do render them in different formats in some uses cases for specific audiences. Nor is it about a final rendered document. It is the details of workflows and collaborations that happen before a document is ever finalized where the the editing and reading experiences must match.