32 ms·
This article confuses bolts and pins... Removing the bolts doesn't really have an impact on strength. A lack of a bolt can cause wear on a pin as the structur
by londons_explore 8y ago
This article confuses bolts and pins...
Removing the bolts doesn't really have an impact on strength. A lack of a bolt can cause wear on a pin as the structure flexes, but typically unless you're leaving it for years that wouldn't be an issue. You can inspect the wear the next time you use the pin.
Removing pins weakens the structure substantially. However when the crane isn't in use, it doesn't need anywhere near all of it's strength, so removing one of two pins is fine.
I would guess in this case, they removed 2 of 2 pins, leaving gravity the only thing holding everything in place, which is plain stupid.
- dmurray 8y agoCan you explain the difference some more? I think of a bolt as a pin with threads, that gets secured with a nut on the other end. A pin has no thread and gets secured by putting another piece through a hole in the end of it. So they have different failure modes (a bolt can get its thread stripped, or vibrate the nut off) but otherwise can be used interchangeably. What's the structural difference you are referring to?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoBolts are (generally?) intended to apply force between two surfaces and not themselves act as shear resistance. Whereas a pin is (generally?) entirely a shear-force resistance component.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoRight. Bolts are usually weak in shear but strong in tension.Their job is to create high friction between two pieces; that friction joins the two pieces as one.
- tyingq 8y agoSee this diagram: https://static.seattletimes.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/crane-pins-WEB-1020x602.jpg https://static.seattletimes.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/c... I believe the metal sleeves that the bolts go into are the pins. Edit: I probably shouldn't have said "sleeves". That has more than one meaning in this context. I'm talking about hollow pins, secured by bolts when I say "sleeves".
- appleflaxen 8y agoWait... isn't that exactly what londons_explore says is wrong, and essentially the source of confusion in the first place?
- tyingq 8y agoI think it's right. He seemed to be describing hollow pins with threaded holes. The pins hold the sections together, the bolts screw into, and steady the pins.
- londons_explore 8y agoCorrect. What I said only applies to this particular use of bolts to hold pins in place, which in turn hold the truss together.
- a2tech 8y agoWatch this video for a good breakdown of what people think happened: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cexN2-T6dxY&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cexN2-T6dxY&feature=youtu.be he has a followup video with additional pictures sent in from the scene that seems to corroborate his thoughts
- hedora 8y agoPrimary source is here: https://towercranesupport.com/tower_crane_accidents.php https://towercranesupport.com/tower_crane_accidents.php Simply loosening bolts to “hand tightened” has led to crane collapses. (The article under the Worthton accident on page one summarizes expert witness testimony to this effect) In general, removing even one element from a truss structure substantially lowers safety margins. Also, crane collapses often happen during assembly and disassembly, since that is when unexpected things often happen. Unnecessarily removing redundancy from the structure increases the chances of such collapses.