4 ms·
As someone who watches the very unusual moderation of China-critical comments on HN (+3 one moment, -3 a few hours later) I'm wary of a political piece praising
by nailer 8y ago
As someone who watches the very unusual moderation of China-critical comments on HN (+3 one moment, -3 a few hours later) I'm wary of a political piece praising China hitting #1 on HN.
I also don't see the value of Singapore - which is openly anti democratic (https://www.huffpost.com/entry/singapore-challenges-democracy_b_7933188 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/singapore-challenges-democrac...) providing advice here - as the same concerns about authoritarian corruption that apply to China also apply to Singapore.
- ptah 8y agoit is up to each nation to choose it's form of government. it is not one size fits all
- kingkawn 8y agoA friend who grew up in Singapore describes it as the capitalist version of North Korea
- clydethefrog 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disneyland_with_the_Death_Penalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disneyland_with_the_Death_Pena...
- nailer 8y agoSaying the people of China have 'chosen not to choose' is bizarre and disingenuous - you are twisting the notion of freedom to imply Chinese people have chosen not to be free. The Chinese people have never in recent memory chosen the Chinese communist party to represent them exclusively.
- ptah 8y agoas opposed to the illusion of choice provided in de facto two party "democracies"?
- nailer 8y agoYes, there's a world of difference between being able to choose from one option or 2. As to the choice being an illusion because two parties often rule: tell that to the Whigs (one of the two parties that no longer exists in the UK), or to anyone that's held a balance of power in a coalition government.
- ptah 8y agocurrent choices are between different shades of the same colour. it ultimately does not make a difference, it is an illusion
- notfromhere 8y agoone imprisons you for political dissent, one doesn't. "both sides are the same" is intellectually lazy.
- ptah 8y agocompare the resume of xi jinping with that of donald trump and tell me who is qualified for their job: https://qz.com/1103045/chinas-19th-communist-party-congress-a-resume-for-president-xi-jinping/ https://qz.com/1103045/chinas-19th-communist-party-congress-... doing well in a popularity contest a.k.a election is not necessarily an indicator of competence
- nailer 8y agoXi Jinping has no mandate to rule.
- baybal2 8y agoI think it is very polarised topic. I noticed a pattern few month ago: you have a lot of bashing during East coast morning hours, followed by much more conciliatory toned wave of comments few hours after, when East coast wakes up.
- scrape_it 8y ago> As someone who watches the very unusual moderation of China-critical comments on HN (+3 one moment, -3 a few hours later) I'm wary of a political piece praising China hitting #1 on HN. So im not crazy for noticing this...im also highly concerned that HN may not have appropriate vote manipulation filter, and that much of what we read on the front page are increasingly engineered.....
- stevefan1999 8y agomeh, it's probably because white dudes in HN doesn't like to have an Asian, especially Chinese to steal their job opportunities, and so they like to see bashes around China because it doesn't guarantee benefits to them.
- mark_l_watson 8y agoI worked in Singapore in 2016 and in my exploration of various neighborhoods I did not see abject squalor, as seen in East LA, West Chicago, etc. people seemed employed and happy. BTW, your comment on moderation is interesting.
- dangus 8y agoUsually any claim of "poverty doesn't exist here" is not going to be very close to being accurate. https://borgenproject.org/top-10-facts-about-poverty-in-singapore/ https://borgenproject.org/top-10-facts-about-poverty-in-sing...