42 ms·
Wait, are you saying that watching the video is considered a crime in and of itself? Not redistribution, and not even mere possession, but just seeing it?
by int_19h 8y ago
Wait, are you saying that watching the video is considered a crime in and of itself? Not redistribution, and not even mere possession, but just seeing it?
- PorterDuff 8y agoEvidently you can't even read the manifesto (which involves possession of course. Dunno if you get in trouble for reading it over someone's shoulder). https://qz.com/1579660/new-zealands-manifesto-ban-explained-by-its-chief-censor/ https://qz.com/1579660/new-zealands-manifesto-ban-explained-... According to that article, having a copy is worth 10 years in the pokey.
- stallmanite 8y agoWell that makes me want to go read the damn thing. Good job NZ. This is why you get left off maps.
- Taniwha 8y agoCertainly, like child porn, watching snuff movies was already illegal in NZ before the alt-right terrorist attack, all the NZ censor did was confirm that the snuff movie fell under that category, it was essentially born illegal. No one passed any special new laws to make it so. It also falls under the US supreme court test for obscenity and is equally illegal in the US
- asdf21 8y ago>It also falls under the US supreme court test for obscenity and is equally illegal in the US I don't think that's correct. There are no federal obscenity laws. The U.S. government does not expressly prohibit obscene conduct. In fact, the U.S. government expressly protects some communications in the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. https://legalcareerpath.com/obscenity-law/ https://legalcareerpath.com/obscenity-law/
- Taniwha 8y ago18 USC 71 ... is the federal obscenity law, it's been much patched in and around child porn, but the basic law is still there. Of course there's been a lot of Supreme Court rulings in and around it culminating in the Miller test ... Your 'shooting video' is really a snuff film, probably one of the few genuine ones (along with those made by ISIS, and just as bad) and certainly falls under the Miller test
- asdf21 8y agoI mean, /r/watchpeopledie was active for nearly a decade and never had legal issues.. I'm not sure this is enforced in any meaningful way.
- Taniwha 8y agoThat doesn't make it legal, or even morally right - people who want to watch this shit are sick fuckers
- asdf21 8y agoWow, that's an incredibly judgey and myopic perspective. And wrong, I believe. I've personally watched a decent amount of gory stuff just because I like to understand the world I live in better. Do you think people who watch violent R rated movies are sick fucks too?
- dredds 8y agoThere's a difference between watching fatal car accidents or faked scenes in movies as opposed to live criminal acts of violence on real people, but there are certainly grey areas too. Who hasn't seen people jumping from the World Trade Center fires? We're drawn to, and learn from, the plight of others, but there are also legal standards to protect real people who are being filmed while being criminally abused, rather than just acting the part in a video portrayal of such.
- 8y ago
- hnaccy 8y ago>It also falls under the US supreme court test for obscenity and is equally illegal in the US I fail to see how a shooting video appeals to the prurient interest in any way.