3 ms·
"Senior scientists are expected to be both a robust support system and a stern, independent assessor of progress — a contradiction that discourages students fro
by musicale 8y ago
"Senior scientists are expected to be both a robust support system and a stern, independent assessor of progress — a contradiction that discourages students from sharing potential mental-health issues for fear of damaging their professional progress."
This is true at all levels. As someone recently pointed out on HN, bundling formal evaluation with teaching makes students cautious, for good reason. It makes it harder on both sides for teachers to help students learn.
Graduate advisors become even more powerful when they control your funding (i.e. ability to eat) as well as your continued presence at the school.
There are similar problems in workplaces where your boss is supposed to be a coach or facilitator but is also expected to be an evaluator who has power over your salary and continued employment.
- LowLevelHacker 8y agoJust left an in patient system after a suicide attempt after my fifth year as a phd student. I blame my advisor 95% for my mental problems, she is a straight lunatic, I hate her so much.