7 ms·
I really wish nuclear power would stop getting all this unnecessary hate - apparently in the grand canyon there was a bucket of uranium[1] sitting in a storage
by munk-a 8y ago
I really wish nuclear power would stop getting all this unnecessary hate - apparently in the grand canyon there was a bucket of uranium[1] sitting in a storage closet, this wasn't particularly dangerous but far more dangerous than a well regulated power plant would be. We need to stop being irrational about the power source that may end up saving the planet.
[1] https://www.npr.org/2019/02/19/696001017/grand-canyon-museum-reportedly-had-buckets-of-uranium-sitting-around-for-18-year https://www.npr.org/2019/02/19/696001017/grand-canyon-museum...
- tobib 8y agoThere is also the problem of nuclear waste being highly radioactive for thousands of years and us not knowing how to deal with it properly.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bargl 8y agoThese are some factiods I've been accumulating on Nuclear, which I'm still trying to refine and learn more about, so any corrections on this would be appreciated if I'm factually wrong: 1) Thorium is safer but isn't being used effectively. Mostly because development of Nuclear power coincided with nuclear weapons, and Thorium can't be used to make weapons. 2) We can re-enrich nuclear waste but don't because of regulations. My understanding here is that the waste product becomes much smaller. 3) We have no clue what were going to do with all the solar panels after we're done with them either? They contain a ton of lead. They also produces something like 1000x the waste mass as nuclear. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying we shouldn't go this route, but I AM saying that we really need to have a wholistic well thought out solution rather than knee jerk fear. 4) If you compare CO2 emissions of France and Germany, one who went all in Nuclear and the other who went all in Solar/Wind. France has significantly dropped their CO2 emissions. 5) Gas power plants are typically used to supplement the downturn in supply of Solar/Wind. Nuclear is a terrible supplement for this. Now Opinion: I think that it's safer in the short term (assuming Global Climate Change for deniers out there) that Nuclear power is a better option for large scale reduction of CO2 Emissions until we have repeatable large scale solutions with solar/wind that are both recyclable and work at night / when wind is down. Because to support Solar/Wind Germany has had to rely on Gas power plants to supplement their gap in supply. Which they sell the excess to their neighbors instead. As I stated above, I'm still digging around forming an opinion on this but it's why I'm at where I am now.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThorium, alternative reactors, reprocessing - all of this requires a lot of research and it's exceedingly expensive. Private entities won't touch it and it's difficult for governments to invest. If the numbers added up China would be doing it already, but even for them - where they can still socialize the costs of failure (i.e. if it blows up, oh well, whereas in the West there's $100B in lawsuits) - it's expensive.
- nitrogen 8y agoPrivate entities won't touch it and it's difficult for governments to invest. Not Thorium, but Bill Gates is invested in alternative nuclear, along with the US govt: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/TerraPower https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/TerraPower
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYes, thorium. And everything else. Gates put $35M into it, which is peanuts. In order to transform Nuclear the R&D will have to be in the order of billions. Drug companies can put more than that into a single failed drug, for comparison.
- keanzu 8y agoA nuclear meltdown in China would call into question the government’s competence. “If an event like Fukushima punctures that image of competence, that’s very, very consequential,” says William Overholt, a China expert at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government. “That would delegitimize the regime.”
- mjevans 8y agoNuclear likes to produce a slow, steady, constant output. If there aren't good on demand fill sources the alternative (point 5) either involves batteries (or another reservoir of some-kind, EG reverse pump hydro; which BTW exists near some river dams) OR a variable consumer. A consumer that doesn't mind getting suddenly cut without warning. This might be an electrolysis process for separating water in to hydrogen and oxygen for industrial applications / chemical fuel production, or it could be some other similar process that might benefit from a stable run cycle but isn't catastrophically affected by loss of power.
- aeneasmackenzie 8y ago1. Dig a hole 2. Put a fence around the hole 3. Put a sign on the fence saying "if you cross this fence you will die" 4. Put radioactive waste in the hole 5. Cover the hole It's not a complicated problem.
- Larrikin 8y agoHow do you prevent it from raining on the fenced off area?
- brianpgordon 8y agoThe way around this is to put the waste in an old salt mine. Salt deposits accumulated there in the first place because it's been dry for thousands of years due to geological features like an impermeable rock dome overhead. The real problem is that nobody wants this waste dump in their state. The Yucca Mountain complex is pretty much perfect for this application but politicians killed it.
- shermozle 8y agoAnd yet it still hasn't been done. Why do you think that is?
- user5994461 8y agoIt's already done. What makes you think it wasn't done?
- zwerdlds 8y agoI hate water tables too.
- D_Alex 8y ago"We cannot guarantee that any simple or complex message, even when recognized and correctly interpreted, will deter a human being from inappropriate action." From https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi/1992/921382.pdf https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi... See also https://www.damninteresting.com/this-place-is-not-a-place-of-honor/ https://www.damninteresting.com/this-place-is-not-a-place-of...
- dTal 8y agoMy understanding was that waste, or indeed any radioactive substance, is either highly radioactive for a short period of time, or not very radioactive for a long time. A mole of stuff has a set number of spare neutrons, and it can release them either quickly or slowly. If it releases them quickly ("highly radioactive"), we can probably get power from it somehow.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- _def 8y agoYour comparison is invalid.
- munk-a 8y agoMy comparison of the dangers of nuclear power to a paint bucket of uranium? As someone who grew up in Boston I have lived within 40 miles of a nuclear power plant for a decent chunk of my life. The times that nuclear power has caused disasters it has always been closely tied to mismanagement and human errors - which are solvable problems if we're open about the costs to utilize nuclear power in a manner more similar to France. I'm pretty sure you're more likely to be killed by a particularly ill mannered seabass than a nuclear power plant explosion (It definitely, for realsies, looks like being struck by lightning is a much more common way to die, but the specific counts are hard to dig up)
- Joakal 8y agoI like nuclear power. But as you point out, human "error" is why I'm against it. It was not even human error for Fukushima, they had ignored experts because the solution would hit the company's bottom line. So the solution is having it government owned. But unfortunately, there's a clear history of governments selling assets. Sorry, but until there's tiny reactors, the risk is huge because; human nature not science. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-japa-nuclear-risks/special-report-japan-engineers-knew-tsunami-could-overrun-plant-idUSTRE72S2UA20110329 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-japa-nuclear-risks/specia...
- tcbawo 8y agoDoes the decommissioning process for a nuclear plant involve returning the space to other uses? Does it become a permanent dead zone? Half-lives of thousands of years are no joke. Practically infinite is a long time.
- jcrawfordor 8y agoYes. In the United States the NRC requires that civilian nuclear power plants be remediated to a point where the property can be released for unlimited use within 60 years of termination of the license. Most of this time span is provided for financial reasons, not technical, as decommissioning is financially secured by a trust fund which gains value with time (the use and investment of which is monitored by the NRC). The NRC does recognize an "entombment" state for facilities in which they are secured so as to be permanently safe, but this does not remove the 60-year requirement, so is usually done when another facility on the same site still has an active license, preventing full-site remediation.
- paulddraper 8y agoGreat is the enemy of good. Nowhere is this proven stronger than in alternative energy. Nuclear is proven, practical, and we have technological benefit of decades of experience. If finding alternative energy was really necessary (and thanks to the abundance of coal and the tragedy of the commons, it won't be for ages), there wouldn't even been a discussion.
- apcragg 8y agoThe thing is, nuclear power straight up isn't profitable to build now. 15 years ago, sure, but according to Lazard's most recent analysis, nuclear power is beaten by alternative sources with storage. The cost of financing projects on such large timescales is huge, not to mention the risk of fiascos like the one going on in South Carolina and to some extent Georgia. We should keep the plants we have running, but use the available funding for new renewables. If we really want to go to the nuclear power route, the government should just do what France and China did by nationalizing new nuclear plant construction. The prviate sector is past the point that it makes sense to choose new Nuclear plants over gas baseload or renewables.
- badloginagain 8y agoA lot of the problem comes from the excessive, ridiculous, way-too-onerous over-regulation of nuclear power plants. Over-regulation brought on by an irrational fear of nuclear power- a fear fostered (and herein I put my conspiracy theory hat) by oil lobbying groups, who identified nuclear as one of the few energy solutions that would jeopardize their energy monopoly. What I never understood is why Exxon/BP/etc never positioned themselves to corner nuclear/solar/etc. At their level, pivoting from being a "Gas Company" to an "Energy Company" seems like a no-brainer. Who cares which energy source wins, if you own all the energy sources?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- keanzu 8y agoIn the West over-regulation destroyed nuclear as a viable option a long time ago. However even where there is no over-regulation there are still economic problems - China hasn't broken ground on a new reactor since 2016. Nuclear is too expensive. https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612564/chinas-losing-its-taste-for-nuclear-power-thats-bad-news/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612564/chinas-losing-its-...
- jpdus 8y agoYou are the one being irrational here. Nuclear power is just way too expensive (when done safely at today's standards) and can't compete in any way with renewables, if you start to factor in all associated costs (e.g. insurance, waste management and security,...) which the government/taxpayer usually has to bear. Nuclear power won't save the planet, but given the political will and investments we have all necessary instruments to get to 100% carbon-free power sources available today (better, cheaper and more sustainable than fission nuclear).
- solveit 8y ago> given the political will Don't gloss over this that quickly, this is literally the hardest part. You might as well wish for a viable commercial fusion plant. Honestly, it's probably easier than getting China to go carbon-free.
- rayiner 8y agoWe don’t—grid scale battery technology is a necessary piece of the puzzle. The only reason renewables work at all is that we have sufficient fossil fuel capacity to cover the entire demand.
- dTal 8y agoSeems a tad unfair to cost in complete lifecycle analysis for nuclear but not its competitors. And the assertion that it can't compete "in any way" with renewables seems to omit some salient advantages - it has the potential to provide constant, basically unlimited power with virtually no land use and no ecological disruption of any kind.
- jpdus 8y agoVirtually no land use, despite nobody wanting to live besides a nuclear reactor? My argument was that renewables can provide the same unlimited power (and the "constant" part can be done via batteries or other means, given sufficient investment. No other energy source comes even close to nuclear when it comes to "hidden" lifecycle costs. Alone the fact that a nuclear plant is not insurable shows, that nuclear depends on enormous public subsidies and will never be commercially viable on itself. Interesting that I am getting downvoted without anyone providing any arguments or facts against my narrative.
- acct1771 8y agoClarification - Feb. 19, 2019 A previous version of this story didn't explain that the proximity to uranium ore described was unlikely to cause health problems, and it referred to uranium instead of uranium ore.