3 ms·
This is how I feel climate change will be tackled (whether too late or not). It will just become cheaper to go green and being green is just a side effect.
by Waterluvian 8y ago
This is how I feel climate change will be tackled (whether too late or not). It will just become cheaper to go green and being green is just a side effect.
- sundvor 8y agoYet initiatives like Carbon tax have been shot down (Australia) by big money, putting dangerous delays into the schedule.
- jlarocco 8y agoI think carbon taxes are the opposite of what the OP is talking about. Carbon taxes are artificial barriers to using fossil fuels. On the other hand, when technology improves so that electric cars cost less per mile than gasoline cars, people won't necessarily buy them to be green, they'll buy them because they're a cheaper form of transportation that happens to be greener. Same with wind and solar power. When a solar farm on 10 acres of land can produce more energy than a coal plant on the same 10 acres, then power companies will build them instead of coal - not to be "green", but to make more money.
- sundvor 8y agoFair point, and an important one! As we're running out of time we ideally need both to happen, but it's good that green tech is becoming increasingly more financially viable. As a little gem, just about all reports from the SA Tesla battery installation make for simply fantastic reading.
- kebman 8y agoCars are a red herring. Even gasoline and diesel car aren't really contributing that much to world pollution compared to the real culprits, such as ocean liners and huge cargo ships. These ships alone pollute more than all the cars on Earth. What do you think about going after the things that are actually harmful, instead of following a red herring? I mean, sure, cars should of course be dealt with also, but if you really want to lower carbon emissions fast, then shouldn't we go for the big fish first?
- johnr2 8y ago> These ships alone pollute more than all the cars on Earth. Do you have a link to figures that show this?
- TranceMan 8y agoI was intrigued - seems it could be because ships use heavy oil https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-the-15-biggest-ships-in-the-world-produce-more-pollution-than-all-the-cars https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-the-15-biggest-ships-i...
- johnr2 8y ago> https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-the-15-biggest-ships-i.. https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-the-15-biggest-ships-i.... Thanks for the link. So it isn't carbon emissions that exceed those of cars but SOx and NOx (which are still a problem).
- daveFNbuck 8y agoCarbon taxes aren't artificial barriers. There are real costs to emitting carbon. Putting a price on negative externalities helps align incentives properly so the people making the coal plant have to consider the full costs of their actions.
- kebman 8y agoWhy not talk to the coal plant owner directly? Or how about the other 100(!) private citizens living around the world who control the companies that are responsible 70% of the greenhouse emissions of the entire Earth?
- pjc50 8y ago> Why not talk to the coal plant owner directly? Well, merely talking to them isn't going to achieve any change, so the plan is to tax them?
- daveFNbuck 8y agoTalking to them doesn't change the economic incentives. No matter how stern of a talking to I give them, they'll still be making a large personal profit at the expense of a larger cost spread across everyone else. Do you think no one has tried talking to any of these people about climate change yet?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y ago> When a solar farm on 10 acres of land can produce more energy than a coal plant on the same 10 acres This is energetically impossible, I'm afraid. Even if you count the area of the plant plus the area of its corresponding mine and the transport links between them. Because the energy density of coal is so incredibly high. On the other hand, now that Drax has switched to burning wood, you might get more energy efficiency from the same (huge) area of woodland by direct solar farming instead. Annoyingly I can't find any numbers, other than an estimate that if Drax was limited to domestic wood (rather than importing it from the US, using oil-fired shipping) it would consume every tree in the UK within a year.
- nathan_long 8y ago> Carbon taxes are artificial barriers to using fossil fuels. > On the other hand, when technology improves so that electric cars cost less per mile than gasoline cars, people won't necessarily buy them to be green, they'll buy them because they're a cheaper form of transportation that happens to be greener. Carbon taxes are like trash disposal fees. If your business dumps trash into the landfill or carbon into the atmosphere, the public should not have to subsidize your business by paying for that. You should pay to manage your own waste. Gas cars are cheaper than electric at least partly because we're all subsidizing them by allowing them to dump waste for free into the air that we all own, and paying on their behalf for all the damages that causes (asthma, climate change, flooding, etc). A carbon tax would remove that subsidy and make fossil fuels compete on a level playing field. And yes, once the subsidy is removed, the market can sort it out.
- kebman 8y agoPoliticians trying to save the environment: Policitian #1: Um, I can't think of anything. Can you? Policitian #2: I got it! Let's make a new tax! It'll annoy these guys, while we'll insure our state jobs, and it'll make state finances look a ton better for all posterity! Policitian #1: Yeah, that sounds really great and all, umm, but will it fix the problem with greenhouse gases? Policitian #2: Don't be silly! This is as good a reason to make the state richer than any.
- luckydata 8y agoHopefully we don't all die in wildfires, food and clean water shortages before then.
- Waterluvian 8y agoMillions of people are displaced yearly by war. It'll just be by climate change too. It's not new for us. It's just more of the same awfulness. Humanity will be fine. We just will have to learn to live without all the cool stuff we like, like polar bears and butterflies and Amsterdam.
- outworlder 8y ago> We just will have to learn to live without all the cool stuff we like Like arable land.
- zaroth 8y agoYou lose arable land at the equator and gain it closer to the poles. Studies don’t generally see a large net decrease in arable land due to climate change. Erosion is the bigger problem, 1/3rd of all arable land lost over the last 40 years. [1] [1] - https://www.businessinsider.com/earth-has-lost-a-third-of-arable-land-in-past-40-years-2015-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/earth-has-lost-a-third-of-ar...
- luckydata 8y agoIn the next 40 we will lose the rest of it. It's going to make a lot of folks very hungry, have you read "the road"? I would rather not live there, thank you very much.
- rectang 8y agoIn idle moments, I daydream of a wager where people who are concerned about climate change bet with those who are unconcerned. If climate change turns out to be mild, the unconcerned get the money. If it's severe, they die.
- kebman 8y agoHahaha it won't be cheaper at all. At some point people will just realize that, hey, being alive is sweeter than being dead. :D