4 ms·
Two scenarios: Cynical scenario: the trusted-source catspaws have been reliable sources in the past, and will seemingly continue to be reliable sources in the
by derefr 8y ago
Two scenarios:
Cynical scenario: the trusted-source catspaws have been reliable sources in the past, and will seemingly continue to be reliable sources in the future. This is their “price” for giving up reliable information for free—the ability to be used as a mouthpiece by their organization. Bloomberg accepts this deal, because they’re so useful otherwise.
Noble scenario: the sources didn’t want to transmit this information any more than Bloomberg wanted to receive it, but they were forced to (by, perhaps, a National Security Letter; or just generic “we’ll hurt your family” coercion); Bloomberg knows this, and doesn’t want to hurt the sources either, when it isn’t their fault (and either don’t know who coerced them; or do know, but know that it’s an actor powerful enough that they know that reporting the source’s coercion would just mean the source’s untimely death. It’s not like a newspaper is a government that can offer witness protection.)
- ikeboy 8y agoCynical version rings truer to me. But the number of different sources they claimed is surprising.
- ikeboy 8y agoThe flip side is that on a story this big, they shouldn't publish if they won't be able to burn their sources if it turns out they're being played. If a source is too valuable to challenge, they're not worth enough to publish. Spin is one thing, outright lies is another.