4 ms·
As a longtime reader who pitched a few bucks at the OotS kickstarter years and years ago, I do still get occasional progress reports to my inbox. The last one w
by kibwen 8y ago
As a longtime reader who pitched a few bucks at the OotS kickstarter years and years ago, I do still get occasional progress reports to my inbox. The last one was from September: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/599092525/the-order-of-the-stick-reprint-drive/posts/2288387 https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/599092525/the-order-of-...
A choice quote: "While there, you may also notice that it's the tenth wallpaper I've released, so that means the wallpaper reward is officially finished. One thing I saw when posting this last one, though, is that it's been so long since the first one that the screen resolutions I've been putting these out at are a little dated in some cases—especially with regard to phones. Is Windows Phone even a thing anymore? And I know the iPhone has completely different screen sizes now, right? So if you have a device that isn't represented with any of those resolutions, go ahead and comment on this post with what screen sizes you'd like to see, and I'll try to go back and add like 5 or 6 of the most popular for all ten wallpapers by the next time I send out an update."
Also be sure to check out the image of his "workometer", which he's been using to track his reward fulfillment progress since the very start. It's nearly all complete by now, but some of the remaining items are substantial.
If I had to guess at what his folly was, I'd say it was simply overpromising with the stretch goals for various milestones. Remember that this was in the early heyday of Kickstarter, and few people had any experience with what an absolute slog fulfillment would turn out to be. I commend him for sticking it out regardless when so many other projects have just defaulted.
- scott_s 8y agoIn retrospect, I think the biggest mistake early kickstarter campaigns made was to promise merchandize unrelated to the primary thing being promised. Such things detract from the main mission, not add to it. Stretch goals should be more of the main thing (longer support for the webcomic, extra content in the videogame, extra episode of a series, etc), not tangential things (shirts, posters, stickers, just about any physical item). The other thing is that the Patreon model did not exist in the early Kickstarter days, and a lot of things are better suited to the periodic small payments for an indefinite period of time than an up-front campaign.
- mcv 8y agoAlso, it seems many people didn't realise that the work from physical stretch goals grows quadratically, rather than linearly: the more stretch goals you meet, the more products you need to create, and the more people those products need to be sent to. Stretch goals always sound awesome, but people running a Kickstarter should be very conservative with them. The focus should be on the primary product, not the stretch goals, and stretch goals can get in the way of the primary product. Reaper Miniatures had a spectacular Kickstarter with their Bones line, that was famous for the amazing value brought by the enormous number of stretch goals they met, but it worked for them, because their stretch goals were more of the same: more miniatures; and because clearly they did the math: every stretch goal they met was spaced further apart, and about half the stretch goals were not free stuff, but extra options to buy. After this, everybody went nuts with the stretch goals, but many people messed up and ruined the main product with all the stretch goals.