2 ms·
I'm surprised to not to see inertial storage there And by no means is the "duck curve" or storage an impediment for adoption. I will not go as far as identifyi
by baybal2 8y ago
I'm surprised to not to see inertial storage there
And by no means is the "duck curve" or storage an impediment for adoption. I will not go as far as identifying it as a "core" issue here.
- neltnerb 8y agoI wouldn't take offense, it's rare for our personal pet technologies to make it into high level documents. These are just Gates' opinion of the best ones after all. But I would put my money on reflow batteries in the long run if they weren't so far behind, simply the decoupling of storage capacity from power density feels like an engineering perfect storm to me. I was lucky enough that my pet technology made it in =) Why do you think inertial storage might be superior? I've talked to a fair number of people working on it and it sounds totally doable but I'm unclear that it actually costs less per joule stored or why it would. Granted a flywheel costs less per unit mass and compressed air is cheap, but on a capacity and fabrication basis? Maybe. I don't think I'd call it a shoo-in though and wouldn't invest in it myself.
- baybal2 8y ago> Granted a flywheel costs less per unit mass and compressed air is cheap, but on a capacity and fabrication basis? Maybe. I don't think I'd call it a shoo-in though and wouldn't invest in it myself. Its power and energy density is next to nothing in the industry. Fabrication, cost on the market? Even most basic flywheels like one used as industrial UPSes can be used right away for grid storage, and be more or less competitive with their high round-trip efficiency. This just shows that how low a commercial opportunity for energy storage as such is. You need truly monstrous daily variations in energy price to make people put money it it.
- baybal2 8y agoBy the way, I'm talking about regular steel flywheel, not carbon fibre ones