8 ms·
Doctors and decision fatigue
- apawloski 8y agoMy colleague recently recommended the book "Why We Sleep" by Matthew Walker. While I was expecting it to tout the benefits of good sleep, I was surprised at the evidence around the inverse: not getting a full night's sleep is alarmingly bad for you. The evidence suggests that this extends far beyond cognitive and psychological health impacts. For example, the author notes that there is a 24% increase in heart attacks the day after we lose an hour of sleep during daylight savings. This is just the tip of the iceberg, in my opinion. Given these mental and physical risks, it is insane that we allow physicians to routinely work shifts that endanger themselves and lead to measurable drops in their performance.
- bigred100 8y agoI believe we need to do away with “the Kaiser’s trick hour” and restore a truly reliable, truly American sense of time
- mattsouth 8y agoThere's talk of doing away with it in Europe: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2019/mar/26/when-do-the-clocks-go-forward-change-2019-daylight-savings-time https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2019/mar/26/when-do-the-...
- salty_biscuits 8y agoThe Kaiser? I always thought it was Adenauer...
- blauditore 8y ago>For example, the author notes that there is a 24% increase in heart attacks the day after we lose an hour of sleep during daylight savings. How did the author directly attribute those stats to the "lost" hour of sleep? Even apart of the fact that people don't necessarily lose an hour of sleep, there could be many other reasons. It sounds like a case of conflating causality with correlation.
- apawloski 8y agoI am reasonably confident that the author is aware of the distinction between correlation and causation. If you're interested or skeptical, I would highly recommend this book. It's from the "Sleep Loss and the Cardiovascular System" section of Chapter 8. He includes chapter endnotes discussing sources.
- Aromasin 8y agoI'm currently reading this book at the moment. The part of it that discusses the disastrous effect of the removal of the biphasic "siesta" sleeping in Spain, versus those that maintain it, had a distinct impact on me. I honestly think that we culturally need to return to this. I work on a team of engineers and you can see people flag around this time, yet they'll grab a cup of coffee and struggle through. It makes you wonder how many errors are solely due to this sleep deprivation that is now all so common. I highly recommend people read it. I've gone from getting into bed about 11 and waking up around 6, to getting into bed at 9 and waking up before my alarm clock even goes off, and having a 20 minute nap at lunch. The difference in my mood and energy levels, and most amazingly memory, has been stark. I miss out on an hour of reading or games, but I feel like I actually have more time because I'm alert - not in that state of flux where I'm gormlessly staring at my book or computer with nothing actually happening in my head. You won't realise how sleep deprived you are until you're not, and I would never have changed my perspective if I wasn't given the statistics that he presents in this book.
- faceplanted 8y agoAll these go to bed early stories sound great until I remember that the majority of my social life happens from 9PM-1AM
- Aromasin 8y agoAn unfortunate reality but at least that means sleep deprivation only needs to happen 1-3 times a week, not every night like I got used to. The difference between 7 hours sleep a night to 8 hours during the midweek days has made the biggest impact on my life. The book discusses that the difference between 7 hours and 8 hours has almost as much an effect on you as that of 5 hours and 7 hours. The last moments before you wake up seem to be the part when the electrical "waves" that happen during REM sleep are at their strongest, but sadly it's that REM cycle particular that almost everyone misses. I'm a night owl forced into a day time job (if given the option I'd happily stay up till 2am), so I struggle with getting to sleep early - but now I've learnt how important it really is I'm much more motivated to force myself to do it.
- jhayward 8y agoI've long advised my family and friends: "always take the 1st appointment or flight of the day. Never book the end of the day's schedule" for doctors visits and airline flights. Chaos, delay, and error compound themselves throughout the day and then get reset to baseline overnight.
- prdonahue 8y agoI read this as I dread waking up to board a flight at 5:20am leaving Austin.
- draugadrotten 8y agoThat, or after a break or meal is the best to meet the judge. "They found that the likelihood of a favourable ruling peaked at the beginning of the day, steadily declining over time from a probability of about 65% to nearly zero, before spiking back up to about 65% after a break for a meal or snack." https://www.theguardian.com/law/2011/apr/11/judges-lenient-break https://www.theguardian.com/law/2011/apr/11/judges-lenient-b...
- dredmorbius 8y agoDebunked. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19915540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19915540
- jonas21 8y agoThe author uses the Israeli parole board study as an example supporting his case, but doesn't mention that the study failed to account for other factors that might affect parole decisions. When other researchers took a closer look, it turned out that in each session, prisoners without attorneys (who are less likely to be granted parole) were scheduled last, just before the breaks. After accounting for this and several smaller factors, the original conclusion could no longer be supported. [1] [1] https://www.pnas.org/content/108/42/E833.full https://www.pnas.org/content/108/42/E833.full
- yig 8y agoEgo Depletion, which is related, failed to replicate in a pre-registered, 23-lab, 2141-participant replication study. [1] [1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1745691616652873 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1745691616652873
- danieltillett 8y agoAlmost nothing is psychology replicates apart from g.
- _the_inflator 8y agoTaleb has you covered: https://medium.com/incerto/iq-is-largely-a-pseudoscientific-swindle-f131c101ba39 https://medium.com/incerto/iq-is-largely-a-pseudoscientific-...
- challenger22 8y agoThe criticisms he makes against IQ are pretty easy to argue against. 1. So it looks like any correlation against IQ is strongest at IQ's < 100. This is a fine conclusion and shows an important result- as your IQ increases, your life outcomes are more dependent on other personality factors and choices. He knocks this as a "no correlation existing" for high IQ's, even when you can see the damn correlation on his scatterplots (even after he blacks out large portions of them). 2. For income vs. IQ, there will be high variance. This is obvious. 3. He intentionally omits R-values for many of his plots to hide their predictive power. Even smaller R-values, given a large sample size and good p-test, show the power of a correlation.
- agumonkey 8y agoI think we need a push up toward a simpler and slightly denser monitoring culture across the whole board. Just enough so everybody can keep the rate but decrease the errors.
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoI'm one that likes(liked) to schedule doctors appointments in the afternoon. My experience has been a bit negative. I've had doctors that rush because they are running late, inattentive because they are tired, cancel because they have other appointments, doctors that seem to want to discuss their previous cases, and they have plainly told me that they can only give me a few minutes because they have other things to do. I suspect that even the ones that are attentive are thinking about other things than my situation. It turns out that doctors are people too. So I completely agree an AM appointment is your best bet if you want to get the best service from the doctor.
- GavinMcG 8y agoRelated quasi-counterpoint: http://m.nautil.us/blog/impossibly-hungry-judges http://m.nautil.us/blog/impossibly-hungry-judges
- blt 8y agoIf you want the attention of a crowd, speak at 10am. Any earlier, the night people won't be well-rested. 11am, the morning people become hungry for lunch and impatient. After lunch, anyone who overate will be sleepy. By the time everyone's digested their lunch, the older morning people are fading for the day. 10-11am is the golden hour.
- newsbinator 8y agoThis is surprisingly poorly understood by everyone from consultants and sales people to speaking coaches. It doesn't matter what you say or how you say it (within reason) if you're battling against your audience's metabolism the whole time.
- scruple 8y agoMy favorite is half-day or all-day meetings where they always plan out 10 minutes for a break every hour and it just slips and slips. You end up being lucky if you can get 10 minutes of an "official" break in a 4 hour window. I've taken to just getting up and walking away for my 10 minutes. I have to piss. I need a coffee, or some water, or just the opportunity to go and breath some other stale air in some other corner of the office (I work full-time remote, so it's generally my own stale air, but the point remains). How is this lost on so many people? It strikes me as being so basic and so obvious and I feel like I invariably end up looking like an asshole because I can't sit in a chair and listen to people fill a volume of space with their words for 2 hours straight.
- B1FF_PSUVM 8y ago> people fill a volume of space with their words for 2 hours straight. And those are the run of the mill self-lovers. Real pros like Fidel Castro and others of the ilk could go solo for up to 7 hours. (The other day heard from someone who attended one of those speeches. Not a happy memory, for some reason.)
- keyle 8y agoUnrelated, but how many nytimes employees are here upvoting nytimes stories? It has to be right, unless they're the last quality publication on earth, it's everyday... (nytimes.com) (nytimes.com) (nytimes.com) (nytimes.com) (nytimes.com)... Don't get me wrong I'm not saying they do bad work. It's just hackernews has become a lot less about hacker news. (Edit: and the downvotes came flying in...!)
- cm2012 8y agoNYtimes is probably the most reputable news source on earth. I incredibly doubt there's a significant number of NYTimes employees here.
- hydrox24 8y agoIt may be amongst them, but do not discount other organizations with a similar pedigree merely because they're not American. Financial Times, The Economist, and so on. At any rate, this article is an opinion piece along with plenty of other NYTimes articles posted to Hacker News. When judging an opinion piece the the pedigree and reputability of the newspaper matters much less.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- freddie_mercury 8y agoThat is true but HN is overwhelming an American readership, which is obvious to non-Americans or anyone who lives outside of the US timezones. Which isn't too surprising, all things considered, it just is what it is. But given all too human "familiarity bias", it also isn't surprising that an American readership submits & upvotes primarily American sources.
- solveit 8y agoTangential, but I would be very interested in a census of HN. Does anyone know if this has been done?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoFrom the reference JAMA study: As the clinic day progresses, clinicians may fall behind schedule and experience decision fatigue I wish the paper tried to differentiate which of these two it was. My guess is that it would have more to do with falling behind schedule than decision fatigue. When you are already behind schedule, you at least subconsciously try to do stuff that minimizes your time. Having a long talk about required screening or arguing about antibiotics may not feel very worthwhile to you when you have 6 patients that have been waiting an hour for you.
- criddell 8y agoI always try to get the first appointment of the day. The thing that annoys me to no end is that doctors are already running late by that time. Sometimes I think there's a basic lack of respect for their patient's time.
- adolph 8y agoMaybe doctors should work less? Hospitalization with acute myocardial infarction during Transcatheter Cardiovascular Therapeutics meeting dates was associated with lower 30‐day mortality, predominantly among patients with non–ST‐segment–elevation myocardial infarction who were medically managed. https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/JAHA.117.008230 https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/JAHA.117.008230
- code_duck 8y agoFor some reason, society has this observational attitude about these practices. It’s not clear to me at all while medical institutions think doctors and nurses need to work excessive amounts of hours in a row with no rest.
- retiredcoder 8y agoI guess real doctors can be more precise than me here. However, at where I live only doctors working with trauma/ER work long hours. From what I understand, that’s mostly to work around the overhead of context switch and patient hand over. For my friend, a lot of stress came from the responsibility, which might not be well distributed across specializations (hence the insurance premiums, etc).
- code_duck 8y agoIt just doesn’t seem to me that having a doctor who has been awake for 22 hours straight is preferable to handing the patient over to a doctor who has slept within the last day.
- ikeyany 8y agoI wonder how doctors would feel about reducing their hours/pay by a third. To be honest, I'd prefer that.
- netwanderer3 8y agoFor those who need to take a driving test, it's always best to try schedule it for the earliest morning time slot. The examiners typically don't want to start off their day by being a prick and fail someone.
- bitL 8y agoImagine having the purest ideals of helping people when entering medical profession, only to end up burned out, going through motions, knowingly but hopelessly harming your own patients, leading you to substance abuse to cope with that as the system is set up to drive you to the brink of collapse. I am wondering what kind of sociopaths designed medical profession guidelines, maximizing unintended damage, depriving doctors of any quality off-time for their own recovery.