3 ms·
I mean, it's not that expensive to just take some hi-res X-ray photos of old and new boards of the same make, and compare the trace paths near each component. M
by derefr 8y ago
I mean, it's not that expensive to just take some hi-res X-ray photos of old and new boards of the same make, and compare the trace paths near each component. Maybe you can even take a visual diff of the X-ray negatives, if you can get everything lined up tightly enough.
You can parallelize this search, because the people doing it don't need to know much about what they're looking for—they're just hunting for visual differences. Unless/until one of them actually finds anything different. At that point, you need better resources to figure out what's different; but at that point, all hell also breaks loose, and you'll get all the resources and help you need to do better analyses.
- cantrevealname 8y ago> Unless/until one of them actually finds anything different ... at that point, all hell also breaks loose Boards bought weeks or months apart might have lots of differences in traces and components due to engineering modifications and normal changes in suppliers. Do you really think that all hell would break loose if you showed that there were differences between a Supermicro board made in March 2018 and one made in September 2018? Other than maybe Supermicro or intelligence agencies (who aren't talking), I doubt that anyone has done what you've suggested. People are busy and it's a lot of work based on an allegation and no exact place to look.
- errantspark 8y agoIs that really true? Granted I'm working on low volume stuff (1000's of units) in a niche B2B setting, but the times for rolling out a new rev of a board can sometimes be measured in quarters. Changing traces/components can have unforeseen effects for even fairly minor things, you can't just have a Tier1/2 CM tool up without a round of DVT. I doubt boards with the same PN change very often if at all, but I'd be curious to know if i'm wrong.
- nitrogen 8y agoI used to work for an electronics manufacturer. They did use xrays on a regular basis, but mostly to find cracked solder joints under ICs.
- cyphar 8y ago> I mean, it's not that expensive to just take some hi-res X-ray photos of old and new boards of the same make, and compare the trace paths near each component. Maybe you can even take a visual diff of the X-ray negatives, if you can get everything lined up tightly enough. There are examples of attacks which cannot be detected by staring at X-rays of components[1]. Now, to be fair they are very advanced attacks but we know they exist. [1]: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13389-013-0068-0 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13389-013-0068-0