4 ms·
There are references on the page. Follow the links! Two WO patents are cited (linked to), wherein a patent has to provide sufficient data, dislosure etc. to pa
by michaelforrest 8y ago
There are references on the page. Follow the links!
Two WO patents are cited (linked to), wherein a patent has to provide sufficient data, dislosure etc. to pass the patent examiner(s), who is scientifically trained, and ultimately it must be able to stand up to scrutiny in court, by very sophisticated (pharma compa[ny/ies]) assailants. It is a very expensive futility if done without underlying merit.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoYes, I see the links to the patents. I was expecting links to something other than your own patents. (That's actually part of what gives it the "crackpot" vibe - linking to your own stuff.) Some links to info about F1F0 ATP hydrolysis that are not your own research would do a lot.
- michaelforrest 8y agoIt is original new research. Set in its context in the literature by the hundreds of references cited therein. Apologies for not just copying someone else's work. You would be well placed to actually read the patents/data/arguments/cited references. Especially before throwing around labels. At the end of the day, the drugs outperform in independent standardized tests at the National Cancer Institute. One is ready to enter Phase II clinical trials and these are soon to happen (for NSCLC). Yes there is much more work to do. And I am trying to do it. I am the first at this and the whole point of a patent(s) is to keep it like that (for a time): rendering a monopoly incentive that I can hopefully raise money against to move further foreward. Anyone that feels a tantrum coming on about patents, please look at how the crowdfunding campaign has bombed.
- gus_massa 8y agoIf you are asking people money, you must answer their questions. Not the explicit questions, the important one are the implicit questions, like "Are you a crackpot?". > [...] the drugs outperform in independent standardized tests at the National Cancer Institute. One is ready to enter Phase II clinical trials and these are soon to happen (for NSCLC). Does it mean that one of your drugs passed the Phase I trials? It means that it was injected to humans? And they survive?? This is a good signal that you are not a crackpot. (Or you are a very dangerous one :) .) Why is this information not in the fundraiser post?!?! Not in a indirect link, put it explicitly, with a short explanation of what is a "Phase I clinical trial", an a link to the results. Something similar happens with the comparison with Carboplatin (in my other comment). I can Google "Carboplatin", and I finally made the search, but if you are asking me money, put short explanation of why it is interesting to compare to Carboplatin and a link to the Wikipedia page, and save me a few minutes. I trust more the review in a jornal article than in a patent, but each area has it's own problems and uses and customs. But don't expect normal people to be able to read patents. (What is an "embodiment"?) (Don't expect people to follow and read the links neither.) I think that the problem is that the post has too few explicit information. It doesn't have the name or formula of the drug, the attack path, why it is new, why it should be useful. Almost the only explicit technical info is the graph at the bottom. You can try writing a blog post about the previous drug. Write it for someone that has an Engineering degree in Chemistry and understand the difference between a sugar and a fat, but is not a Biology or Medical specialist. (Bonus points, if the blogpost can be read by an Electric Engineer, that knows that there are atoms, but don't care too much about their order.) Add a few graphics, 3 or 4, graphics are good. Post the blog about the previous drug here, and let's hope that it got traction and you get some feedback. Once the main concerns are fixed, use the blog post as a template for a new fundraiser. Something like: * Hello. * My previous drug is very good (copy the whole blog post here) * Why I think my new drug is better (not too long) * Please give me money for a lab test (some additional details)
- michaelforrest 8y agoThe drug going into Phase II isn't the one that the experiment.com page relates to (although they are both disclosed in the same WO patent). There are multiple drugs and so to keep things simple/clear the experiment.com just restricts to the drug it is asking for funding to synthesize. There are word limits when writing an experiment.com page and keeping it simple is emphasized - indeed I fell foul off this time and time again and so most of the writing on that page is barely mine as it was edited so much. But I think for the purpose, how it is now is better than I could have done alone. Understanding the patents is the level which needs to be reached to really understand the work. Indeed, those patents cite patents, which also need to be understood. Hiding from patents is a no go to get on in this field. So, on an experiment.com page, full understanding was never going to come (but the links are there for those sufficiently interested/qualified). But I want to thank you so much for your interest and advice. Very gratefully received. But somewhat academic now as the campaign has near on ended (well short of goal). A shame. But it has happened.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoAh, I see. So you've got the format (and style, and to some degree content) fixed for you by experiment.com? That ties your hands pretty hard. I'd do this (if you can within their rules): Very early on the page, I'd put a link that says "For the technical details, go here." Link to a page that is not on experiment.com. Go deeper there. As I said, if they let you...