6 ms·
That’s a scenario they created. There’s no reason the man in the van can’t hang up a WISP device or whatever. I used to run a field tech services org — it’s not
by Spooky23 8y ago
That’s a scenario they created. There’s no reason the man in the van can’t hang up a WISP device or whatever. I used to run a field tech services org — it’s not that expensive to train new tasks, the hardest thing is hiring reliable people. Your old school HP and IBM CEs would service everything for 95% of service calls.
They are busting the CWA, period.
The same thing happened with National Grid in upstate NY. They’ll use 5 subcontractors and 10 guys to do a job that was handled by a 2-3 man crew 20 years ago. The hilarious thing is that that union didn’t have the stupid separation of duty stuff the contractors do. I saw one instance where they had a subcontractor on site specifically to spray bee spray.
- gridlockd 8y agoIn other words, union labor is so burdensome, it can't even compete with 5x the manpower?
- Spooky23 8y agoMore likely they are aging out the workforce.
- kelnos 8y agoIs there a rational reason why companies would prefer to hire 3-5x the workers to do the same job, just to avoid having to deal with a union? Or is it all just union-related FUD?
- bluGill 8y agoIf you don't have work you don't pay the contractor. You still pay employees. Depending on the work this can be good or bad. When you have employees you also get flexibility in scheduling them. A contractor is expected to have other jobs and sometimes cannot get to your critical need right now. A contractor can sometimes give you a better deal because of those other customers who are willing to pay extra for last minute service.
- kelnos 8y ago> If you don't have work you don't pay the contractor. You still pay employees. It's funny, though; a week or so ago I saw an article posted here by someone who was paid over $20k for a static web page that took him less than a day to build. After he showed up for his first day of work, he went on a 7-week odyssey doing basically nothing because the people who owed him designs and assets weren't ready yet.
- Spooky23 8y agoPush out accountability and compliance issues to the contractor. In a state like NY, workers compensation costs for jobs with ladders are really high, for example. Contracting it out contains the cost. They also turn capex into opex. If you pay the contractor to dig telephone poles as a service, you don’t spend capex on digging equipment.
- dplgk 8y agoPresumably the cost is still passed along since the subcontractor needs insurance for their workers.
- ed_balls 8y agoIf there is a liability that not covered by the insurance the subcontractor can just go bankrupt. AT&T wants to protect their assets.
- dplgk 8y agoNY state doesn't let anyone go without paying for worker's comp. I run a company with remote developers who sit at a desk and I am still forced to pay it. Also, contractee will require contractor to have insurance so they can sue them if needed.
- hinkley 8y agoDon’t forget empire building. Why be some loser with only six employees when you could run a division with forty five people?
- WalterSear 8y agoAnd be paid accordingly.
- hinkley 8y agoAin't that the truth.
- swoongoonz 8y agobut capitalism is efficient
- StreamBright 8y agoWhat does capitalism has to do with unions? It is actually goes against basic capitalism to have a 2 party system where the employee and the employer negotiates the circumstances of work.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> What does capitalism has to do with unions? Capitalism is the problem for the working class that motivates unions as a mitigation.
- anonuser123456 8y agoCapitalism != Monopsony
- StreamBright 8y agoWhat? Where would workers work? Capitalism is not the problem at all.
- anoncake 8y agoIn cooperatives and publically-owned workplaces, of course.
- StreamBright 8y agoLike gulags?
- anoncake 8y agoOn the off-chance that you aren't trolling: A (worker's) cooperative is a company that is owned and democratically controlled by its workers. Gulags were prisons[1]. Since prisoners do often work, you could technically call a prison a publically-owned workplace provided it is actually owned by the public. It would be highly misleading, but technically not entirely wrong. But gulags weren't owned by the public but by an unambiguously dictatorial state, so no, they aren't. I hope this helped clear things up. [1] Calling gulags prisons is quite an understatement, but very bad prisons aren't worker's cooperatives either.
- 300bps 8y agothe hardest thing is hiring reliable people...They are busting the CWA, period. My father in law was a linesman for AT&T, then the various Bell companies then Verizon for 30 years. He started when he was 21 and retired when he was 51 about 15 years ago. He regularly brags how the union would set hour allotments for each job and how he could complete work in 30 minutes that the union required scheduling for 5 hours. Most of the time he spent on the clock involved him hiding his work truck in the woods behind his house and sneaking into his house to work on home improvements while he was being paid. Every once in a while he would get caught doing something wrong and would be suspended. The union would then represent him and provide him groceries and other items during the suspension. Eventually Verizon paid him a lump sum of a quarter million dollars to go away which along with saving money from decades of generous overtime rules including double time and a half on holidays let him retire at the age of 51.
- sandoze 8y agoHow’s that any different than tech workers inflating story points 2x and indulging a work from home day or kicking off early. I mean other than no job security, pension, gold watch and forced obsolescence at 51.
- Spooky23 8y agoNobody knows wtf tech workers do. There was a candy bar commercial where a bunch of suits were eating candy snickering at the lazy construction crew hanging out below. Pretty much captures it.
- petee 8y agoThere will always be people who abuse the support the union offered, like your dad, who gives unions a bad rep - most members work with pride and want to do the best job they can. Time allotted work is intended to ensure jobs are done safely; not everyone will take that long, but it ensures slower workers aren't going to cut corners just to keep schedule. Without a union, your dad would have been expected to take 30min every single time, and lose your job if you don't.
- wuliwong 8y agoWhat is "the CWA"?
- dbcurtis 8y agoCommunication Workers of America union