3 ms·

I would agree the resume prestige has diminished from what it once was, but I think it's a little far to suggest that any rank and file ENGINEER would have comp

by Phlarp 7y ago

I would agree the resume prestige has diminished from what it once was, but I think it's a little far to suggest that any rank and file ENGINEER would have compromised ethics just from choosing to work there. Facebook uses cutting edge tech and pays really well, I would never hold it against an engineer young or old for accepting a position that very likely offered more compensation than they've ever had before. If you are interviewing Facebook execs or management it would seem reasonable to question their ethics.

c0vfefe 7y ago
In fact we can tell from Googlers commenting here on HN that individual engineers often disagree with some of the practices of their (huge) employer.
- yeahitslikethat 7y ago
  Then they should quit. Stand up for what's right. If the engineers quit, the company can't do it anymore. They are all accomplices. For whatever reason they don't stop and thus their ethics are compromised.
neilv 7y ago
Quote fragment that can be interpreted as opposite of what you intended: > I think it's a little far to suggest that any rank and file ENGINEER would have compromised ethics just from choosing to work there. Facebook uses cutting edge tech and pays really well, I give people benefit of the doubt, recognize that sometimes we have to compromise, etc., but let's not hand out ethical freebies in advance.
yeahitslikethat 7y ago
Ethical behavior is immune to "more compensation than they've ever had before." that's the point. If they are continuing in any way to benefit the operation of a business that does those things then they are morally corrupt.
dbcurtis 7y ago
> I think it's a little far to suggest that any rank and file ENGINEER would have compromised ethics They should have the ability to think about the ethical impact of their work, or have awoken to the necessity. “never thought about it” is a worse answer than “I’m OK with it.” I may not hire someone who answers the later, but I can respect them for having a thoughtful answer.

by Phlarp 7y ago

c0vfefe 7y ago

In fact we can tell from Googlers commenting here on HN that individual engineers often disagree with some of the practices of their (huge) employer.

yeahitslikethat 7y ago
Then they should quit. Stand up for what's right. If the engineers quit, the company can't do it anymore. They are all accomplices. For whatever reason they don't stop and thus their ethics are compromised.

neilv 7y ago

Quote fragment that can be interpreted as opposite of what you intended: > I think it's a little far to suggest that any rank and file ENGINEER would have compromised ethics just from choosing to work there. Facebook uses cutting edge tech and pays really well, I give people benefit of the doubt, recognize that sometimes we have to compromise, etc., but let's not hand out ethical freebies in advance.

yeahitslikethat 7y ago

Ethical behavior is immune to "more compensation than they've ever had before." that's the point. If they are continuing in any way to benefit the operation of a business that does those things then they are morally corrupt.

dbcurtis 7y ago

> I think it's a little far to suggest that any rank and file ENGINEER would have compromised ethics They should have the ability to think about the ethical impact of their work, or have awoken to the necessity. “never thought about it” is a worse answer than “I’m OK with it.” I may not hire someone who answers the later, but I can respect them for having a thoughtful answer.