3 ms·
SciAm made the same battlecry (plea) back in the 90s. I supported it then as I support it now. But it didn't work then and won't work now. Because we don't und
by specialist 8y ago
SciAm made the same battlecry (plea) back in the 90s. I supported it then as I support it now. But it didn't work then and won't work now.
Because we don't understand the enemy.
The remedy isn't messaging, framing, engagement, empathy, discussion, or whatever else rational people hope will induce irrationals to step into the light.
Trying to sneak science thru the infotainment propaganda blockade ain't gonna work. And is a waste of effort.
Perhaps the alternative is our own media empire.
Fox News was run at a loss its first decade. Something like $500m/yr is spent, at a loss, on the right wing noise machine. All those popular alt-right sites have patrons.
Does the left have anything comparable? In scale and gumption?
I don't know if it'd work. Reason ain't sexy. Versus the outrage and fear factory. But I'd like to try something new.
--
Also, impartiality and objectivity is a trap. Just tell your story sincerely, unapologetically. The opponents will blather regardless, so don't share your soapbox.
- weberc2 8y agoDo you seriously believe there is a dearth of left-wing mainstream media outlets? And the problem with the politicization of science is not a right-vs-left issue. The left has its own bag of anti-science positions (e.g., blank slatism, anti-GMO, implicit bias, etc). EDIT: Do downvoters question that the majority of prominent news outlets are left-wing or that the left has anti-science positions?
- specialist 8y agoSputnik My mentor's theory is that the assault on reason, America's proud tradition of anti-intellectualism, took a brief hiatus after WWII because the Cold War and the space race required rocket scientists and engineers. So a brief truce of sorts was maintained between the humanists and the know-nothings. Sad to think we'll need an external existential threat like an alien invasion or imminent asteroid strike to pause the food fight.
- povertyworld 8y agoI think it depends on how you define "left-wing". Some consider the "woke capitalism" of corporate media and SV to be "left", others consider only an explicitly anti-capitalist and pro-labor stance to be left.