6 ms·
Isn’t a passport just a basic photo ID? Seems reasonable to ask for on to check people are who they say they are. Everyone already has a passport.
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Isn’t a passport just a basic photo ID? Seems reasonable to ask for on to check people are who they say they are. Everyone already has a passport.
- synaesthesisx 8y agoIsn't a state driver's license considered a basic photo ID? There's no reason not to accept one.
- moate 8y agoSome states have still not gotten with the times and converted to "Real ID" security in their driver's licenses. Because they're easier to fake, they're not always accepted but YMMV.
- FireBeyond 8y agoThat's one spin on it, but more fear-mongered. The more accurate one is that elements of the Federal Government are "unhappy" that some States will issue a Drivers License based on understanding of road laws and practical skills, and not based on demonstration of legal residence or citizenship. Washington, for example, is one. You pass your test, written, practical, pay your fee. They don't ask about your citizenship. So the Federal Government says "Well, we won't allow your DLs to be used federally (or for flying), then".
- vinay427 8y agoWell, this requirement makes sense from a federal perspective, and the ridiculous saga that ensued over getting states to comply (including the seemingly incompetent ones, looking at you California...) points to the "problem" of not having a federal universally accessible ID, including for proof of residence and/or citizenship. If the federal government wants to have an ID that displays legal residence, then they can either entrust the states to do so or issue one themselves, which seems even less politically viable.
- moate 8y agoI genuinely wonder how much xenophobic fear-mongering you would have to drum up in order to get the "Don't Tread On Me" camp to agree to mandatory federal ID. I think you're right, it's much easier to just slip it in on the state level with Licenses. Also, do you think California was being actually inept or just willfully ignorant based on their demographics? I live in NJ and I know we were also one of the laggards. Shocker, we also have a very large immigrant population, and have a AG that issued orders not to assist ICE. Seems like it's probably easier to play coy and just drag your feet on this one. Or it could just be good ol fashioned government bureaucracy and ineptitude.
- plasticchris 8y agoIf you have never travelled outside the US you might not have a passport.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- throwaway55554 8y agoTrue story. Until a few years ago the only place outside the US that I had gone was Canada, so a passport was not needed. Well, I had a trip coming up to a country other than Canada so I finally had to get a passport. Upon beginning the return trip, I was stopped at security. Before I boarded the plane, I was magic wanded ... again. Not wanting to be one of "those" Americans I held my tongue. Upon landing back in the US, I got stopped again at security. Back on home ground I could be as belligerent as I cared to be. But they just ignored me and went about their search. Only thing I could think was it was a new passport. Pissed me off though. That's just stupid.
- fromthestart 8y ago>Everyone already has a passport. I'm pretty sure most native born citizens don't get passports unless and until they make plans to travel internationally.
- chrisseaton 8y agoIsn’t that risky - what if you suddenly have to travel with business and there’s a delay getting a passport?
- kylec 8y agoThis is a feature. "Oh, sorry Mr. Boss, I can't go on that trip because I don't have a passport"
- JohnFen 8y agoI managed to get out of a business trip that way once!
- moate 8y agoNot really? If I work in food service or retail (largest employment sectors), why is my job going to make me travel to Canada? Most people are only leaving the country for pleasure. That's not to say your scenario couldn't exist, it's just not common I would imagine.
- sokoloff 8y agoIf you travel to certain state department locations, you can get a next-day passport easily (and I’ve heard of people getting same day). I got one in 4 days and the employees there acted like that was on the long side of the spectrum of people who appeared in person. I’d recommend planning ahead instead, but in my case I couldn’t give up my soon-to-expire passport as I was traveling and didn’t expect another international trip so soon after expiration (to use the alternate means of proving citizenship and identity rather than returning the old passport book).
- JohnFen 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mehrdadn 8y agoYou find it normal to carry around passports for domestic travel? How often do you travel?
- newsoul2019 8y agoIn the current presidential administration, this has become a very good idea, to carry around excessive proof that you belong in this country....
- chrisseaton 8y agoI travel with work a lot. Seems normal to carry some ID like a passport when travelling, to me. Hotels often ask for ID. You don’t know if your plans will change and you’ll need to fly straight to another country, etc.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> Seems normal to carry some ID like a passport when travelling, to me. Some ID, yes, people try to have one all the time. A passport though? Most people I know only ever carry that for international travel. This is about domestic travel. > Hotels often ask for ID. You don’t know if your plans will change and you’ll need to fly straight to another country, etc. Yes but that's for international travel. We're asking about domestic travel because this affects them just the same.
- scarejunba 8y agoYou’re atypical. People don’t usually have that happen to them (the domestic to international).
- mehrdadn 8y agoI got the impression they fly international and didn't see we're talking about domestic.
- rconti 8y agoI'd venture to say 99.9% of Americans will never find themselves traveling internationally at the drop of a hat, without being able to return home first (!) It's certainly not happened to me, and I'm in the quite unusual position of being someone who's traveled internationally for business on <24h notice. In other words, no, I never take my passport with me unless I leave my house intending to leave the country.
- gumby 8y agoI don't know about everyone but I just looked and was shocked to learn 42% of Americans have passports, 10X the level 25 years ago. Personally I rarely carry any ID at all, and when I do it's a non-"real ID" driver's license, which I have though I don't own a car. Almost anywhere where ID is "required" (including air travel) it turns out that if you don't have any you can still do what you want (note I'm old enough that I don't get carded for alcohol). I generally have ID with me only if I know in advance I'm going somewhere where I cannot do without it, a couple of times a month. I fly more than that! (It's absurd that a driving licenses are also IDs, but that's another discussion).
- mehrdadn 8y ago> I generally have ID with me only if I know in advance I'm going somewhere where I cannot do without it, a couple of times a month. I fly more than that! Wow, what's the procedure like for when you don't have your ID if you don't mind me asking? What do you tell them when they ask why, how do they verify you, how early do you come/long does it take, etc.?
- gumby 8y agoI never make a big deal of it, just say casually, "sorry, I don't have any ID with me". If they really want something I hand over a credit card or business card. In general nobody really has a need for ID and would rather not lose your business. You show up with an Amex platinum card and a haircut no hotel is going to deny you a room just because you don't have ID. When you fly without ID (note: this is different from having ID but refusing to provide it -- I never do this) you just get a pat down search and your luggage looked at, basically. And this is true in general, though some NY buildings really will enforce an ID (absurd! It's just to keep poor people out) and some federal courthouses for some reason. I mean, it's not like people are checking IDs against some watch list when you walk into a building, nor do most people know what all forms of ID look like, so what's the purpose of all that nonsense? So for the ID case, like most things in life, I simply tell the truth. But for SSN I do fib: when asked for SSN (say at a drugstore or whatever) I say "sorry, I'm a foreigner and don't have one". Yes, I have one, but again, most people who ask for an SSN collect it for no reason that is useful to me. If you make a big deal of it then of course people won't want to deal with you -- it's generally not the decision of the person you're talking with anyway. But if you act like it's the most natural thing in the world then life usually just goes on, as it should.
- foenix 8y agoEveryone? I've had once since birth, but it's foolish to think "Everyone already has a passport". As of 2018, only a ~1/3 of US citizens (137,588,631) have an active passport: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/passports/after/passport-statistics.html https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/passports/after/p...
- holy_city 8y agoLess than half of Americans have a passport. [1] And it has nothing to do with photo ID, it's the fact that they forced the states to adopt REAL ID under the pretenses that they would make photo IDs more reliable and difficult to fake (back in 2005), and now they're using the photos they collected to create a facial recognition system. This needs to be voted on by a full session of Congress and debated in the public sphere, not quietly rolled out at a few airports to normalize it. [1] https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/passports/after/passport-statistics.html https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/passports/after/p...
- SoylentYellow 8y agoDo not assume all people have a passport. In the US, there is not much reason to get a passport unless you plan to travel internationally. Due to the high cost of international travel, I would imagine only a small percentage of lower income individuals have a passport. Even getting a passport is expensive. When you think about it, requiring a passport to opt out of facial recognition screening essentially discriminates against lower income people, including the poor and the elderly on fixed incomes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 8y ago> Everyone already has a passport. Most US citizens do not have a passport. Passports are a real pain to get, so people tend not to bother unless they're planning a specific out-of-country trip.
- jandrese 8y agoUS Passports are not especially cheap and expire after 10 years, so if you have no international travel plans it doesn't make sense to get one. I recently got some for my kids for an upcoming trip and it required me to take time off of work to visit the Post Office during a narrow window when the passport clerk is there, whom we had to pay for her services, to then mail off each passport application individually along with original birth certificates and another check to get the passports a couple of months later. Both parents had to be at the post office to process the application. It's a pretty awful process.
- alasdair_ 8y agoAnd the renewal process for young children requires all the same stuff AGAIN. Two parents, original birth certificates etc. No idea why they can't just use the old passport information with an updated photo. They expire every five years too, so that's three difficult trips involved and a fair bit of expense.
- jdeibele 8y agoYeah, but there have been horror stories about one parent who takes the children back to their home country. Typically it's been the dad back to Saudia Arabia but maybe that's just the stories that made the news. The reason (I assume) for the 5-year expiration is that kids look a lot different in 5 years. Here in Portland you can go to several post offices but the easier way is to go to the county headquarters. Very short wait time, photographer on premises (I keep wanting to just stand the kids against a wall but wife vetoes that), etc. Last year I had business on Spring Break and my wife took our kids to British Columbia. I was a little surprised that they made it across the border without a hitch. No notarized letter, etc. We did have to have both parents notarize something for my son to cross the border for Boy Scouts.
- kylec 8y agoI don't have a passport. If I needed one I'd get one, but the need has yet to arise.
- TallGuyShort 8y agoMany citizens who haven't traveled internationally don't have a passport. My American wife and most members of her family have never had occasion to get one. This is a general problem to be solved, though: occasionally videos surface of Border Patrol agents detaining people until they produce proof they're a citizen. Now, green-card and visa holders are indeed required to carry said documents with them. But citizens are not required to carry proof of their citizenship. So the statistics are actually such that a random person not having proof of legal status in the US is more likely to be here legally than not. Unfortunately, thanks to racists, it's considered politically incorrect to even require a photo ID when voting, so I don't see us solving this problem in a satisfactory way soon.
- alasdair_ 8y ago>Unfortunately, thanks to racists, it's considered politically incorrect to even require a photo ID when voting, so I don't see us solving this problem in a satisfactory way soon. Give every citizen access to a completely free ID card, including giving them access to the required supporting documents for free. A lot of people, especially older people and people without a lot of spare cash, simply don't have photo ID. If you're homeless, getting all the documentation needed to get a license is a severe impediment.