4 ms·
And yet, note that this comment continues the discussion-about-the-discussion, rather than focusing on the specific 'unconscionably unethical and criminal' deta
by gojomo 16y ago
And yet, note that this comment continues the discussion-about-the-discussion, rather than focusing on the specific 'unconscionably unethical and criminal' details.
Nothing wrong with that in this context, but it highlights how hard it is to do anything else. It's easier to talk about the reactions and dissemination and censorship and rhetoric. Those are actually more universal topics, and they're unfolding now.
The nitty-gritty of the cable revelations is subject to a interpretation and even more acrimonious rehearsed-roles debate, so (as here) it often just gets mentioned in passing, with a hand-wave and nod to its importance.
Of the cables' revelations, many that people are 'shocked, shocked' to hear are what was already assumed to be true or partially reported -- covert military strikes in other countries, attempts to downplay fatalities or wartime actions in error, frank assessments of shady regimes.
And it seems to me many people are just seeing what they wanted to see. If they already bought into a Chomskyite view of the US as the scheming amoral fount of all evil in the world, there's enough in the cables to feed that view. If they think the US is just another powerful but bumbling country pursuing its interests, fighting several wars, striking balances with sordid situations not entirely under its control, there's enough in the cables to feed that view, too.
What's the one or two things in the cables you found most surprising?
- nitrogen 16y agoI personally was surprised to read that Shell has a significant foothold within the Nigerian government. It caused me to wonder how true the claim is, and whether similar situations exist in other countries with other corporations, perhaps even the US. http://wikileaks.ch/cable/2008/09/08LAGOS368.html http://wikileaks.ch/cable/2008/09/08LAGOS368.html
- notahacker 16y agoOne of the great benefits of the publicity surrounding Wikileaks is that it's encouraging people to look into issues they previously might not have considered. That said, the role of the oil companies in the Niger Delta unrest isn't exactly unknown, not many people labour under the delusion the Nigerian government isn't to some extent corrupt, and the page you linked to isn't even a particularly damning one, as governments do have a legitimate interest in monitoring activities of rebel groups and the effects on multinationals they target. The smoking gun would be finding documents suggesting that events like the Odi massacre were planned (and possible oil company collusion) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odi_massacre http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odi_massacre What's been released recently seems to be the sort of thing that might cause discomfort to a few diplomats who've made rather unflattering and speculative (but in many cases justified) comments about their host countries but it's less than earth-shattering. The half-hearted attempts to discredit Assange feels like an attempt to appease the leaders they've privately insulted; perhpas they have more reason to be concerned about what hasn't been released. Governments have willingly released far more inadvertently damaging material... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodgy_Dossier http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodgy_Dossier
- jdp23 16y agoAgreed, reading about a Shell executive boasting they've infiltrated every single branch of the government is pretty amazing. Also in Nigeria, there was also a cable about a guy from Pfizer telling the US that they were threatening the Attorney General with bad press to get him to drop a multi-billion suit (that was eventually settled for $75). VOA has a good roundup of news about Africa: http://www.voanews.com/english/news/africa/WikiLeaks-Revelations-Could-Have-Serious-Consequences-for-Africa-says-Analyst--111603274.html http://www.voanews.com/english/news/africa/WikiLeaks-Revelat...
- jpablo 16y agoI was surprised that after a private talk between the presidents of Mexico and Spain, the latter went back and immediately gave a summary to the US ambassador in Madrid.
- patrickk 16y agoThe fact that the Saudi king wanted the US to go right into Iran, guns blazing.
- trop 16y agoOr at least told the U.S. that privately. Which is different, as this could just be what he thinks the U.S. wants to hear, while he can say something different to his people in public.
- patrickk 16y agoI doubt he said that because it's what he thinks the US wants to hear. I would imagine he is deeply concerned about Iran creating a destablising influence in the region. You are right about saying something different in public to his subjects though, as such a view would be hugely controversial in the Arab world and a major embarrassment to the king. It seems he wanted the US to strike against the Iranian uranium enrishment program: http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6AP06Z20101128 http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6AP06Z20101128
- pmr_ 16y agoWhat surprised me the most is the apparent willingness of my representatives to share information and cooperate with the reprensentatives of the United States in a way that seems to undermine the sovereignity of their own country. To me as a citizen the US is essentialy a foreign power and I would like it to have no say in the internal affairs of the country I live in without having obvious benefits for me. This doesn't appear to be the case and it isn't because US diplomats apply pressure to get concessions but rather because politicians yield even without pressure.