4 ms·

Just so you know, Walmart is not the underdog. Walmart sells many multiples the volume that Amazon does, and to boot, most of the products sold are owned by Wal

Just so you know, Walmart is not the underdog. Walmart sells many multiples the volume that Amazon does, and to boot, most of the products sold are owned by Walmart. Amazon is merely a fee-taker on the majority of the product sales that it facilitates.

WhompingWindows 7y ago
Can you post evidence to support those claims?
- mediaman 7y ago
  These are not controversial claims. Walmart revenue is $514 billion. Amazon revenue is $232 billion. Currently, about half of the retail revenue of Amazon is marketplace sales, where Amazon does not own the merchandise but simply warehouses it on consignment and charges fulfillment fees, or in some cases simply places a drop-ship order for it.
  - j-c-hewitt 7y ago
    About 70% of Amazon sales are from third party sellers. So if you are comparing apples to apples you have to just look at the ~30% that is direct from Amazon. And with first hand experience with Amazon's Vendor program they go further than a lot of other retailers in pushing costs onto their vendors such as making them eat returns etc.
    - dfrage 7y ago
      > you have to just look at the ~30% that is direct from Amazon. Except due to commingling you might get something from a 3rd party Fulfilled by Amazon instead of Amazon's supply chain. > And with first hand experience with Amazon's Vendor program they go further than a lot of other retailers in pushing costs onto their vendors such as making them eat returns etc. I know Walmart is very severe with their vendors, do you believe Amazon is worse?
      - j-c-hewitt 7y ago
        That number is included in the marketplace vs 1P sales. The 3P seller gets credited when their commingled item is sold. Amazon gets credited for the sale when it is the one they own that is sold. That's how it works. A lot of sellers also opt out of commingling so it is really not as much of a factor as is sometimes portrayed. There are only certain kinds of items that are disproportionately impacted by it. >I know Walmart is very severe with their vendors, do you believe Amazon is worse? I mean, Walmart is harsh, but Amazon is just an insane robot as it relates to most vendors. Think more maliciously dumb than evil.

WhompingWindows 7y ago

Can you post evidence to support those claims?

mediaman 7y ago
These are not controversial claims. Walmart revenue is $514 billion. Amazon revenue is $232 billion. Currently, about half of the retail revenue of Amazon is marketplace sales, where Amazon does not own the merchandise but simply warehouses it on consignment and charges fulfillment fees, or in some cases simply places a drop-ship order for it.
- j-c-hewitt 7y ago
  About 70% of Amazon sales are from third party sellers. So if you are comparing apples to apples you have to just look at the ~30% that is direct from Amazon. And with first hand experience with Amazon's Vendor program they go further than a lot of other retailers in pushing costs onto their vendors such as making them eat returns etc.
  - dfrage 7y ago
    > you have to just look at the ~30% that is direct from Amazon. Except due to commingling you might get something from a 3rd party Fulfilled by Amazon instead of Amazon's supply chain. > And with first hand experience with Amazon's Vendor program they go further than a lot of other retailers in pushing costs onto their vendors such as making them eat returns etc. I know Walmart is very severe with their vendors, do you believe Amazon is worse?
    - j-c-hewitt 7y ago
      That number is included in the marketplace vs 1P sales. The 3P seller gets credited when their commingled item is sold. Amazon gets credited for the sale when it is the one they own that is sold. That's how it works. A lot of sellers also opt out of commingling so it is really not as much of a factor as is sometimes portrayed. There are only certain kinds of items that are disproportionately impacted by it. >I know Walmart is very severe with their vendors, do you believe Amazon is worse? I mean, Walmart is harsh, but Amazon is just an insane robot as it relates to most vendors. Think more maliciously dumb than evil.