3 ms·
Some abstractions are definitely more useful/successful/robust than others. (I think I want to say usually for a particular context, not as a universal/existen
by jrochkind1 8y ago
Some abstractions are definitely more useful/successful/robust than others.
(I think I want to say usually for a particular context, not as a universal/existential thing. Sometimes that context grows to be everyone's... we all use a 'file' abstraction because it was so useful the entire field adopted it, and stopped considering alternative abstractions, and everyone takes as a starting assumption to work within the context where 'file' is useful (except in extreme edge cases maybe) -- for better or worse.)
Deciding which is which, whether a particular abstraction's value outweighs the "leak" in particular contexts or in "general" -- well, that's what endless internet debate is made of. It's usually not clear as a consensus until quite some time has passed (and even then heretics can challenge it).
I agree it's the right question, but it can't be answered simply by saying "leaky abstraction".