2 ms·
Two reasons. 1. UBI can be politically impossible. 2. You want to give incentive that is not local (individual level the best use of money) and becomes benefi
by nabla9 8y ago
Two reasons.
1. UBI can be politically impossible.
2. You want to give incentive that is not local (individual level the best use of money) and becomes beneficial only when it applies to everyone. One individual does not generate enough inertia to change bus service, it's mass transit. If you give a nudge that changes the behavior of many people, you can reach states that individual incentives can't reach.
There are sub-fields of economy that study reasons why markets don't solve all issues. For example the "Theory of company." Why we have companies made of large number of people where internal structures and incentive structures are shielded from markets forces? Those same questions related to issues of what government should do and not to do.
- luckylion 8y agoIt wouldn't need to be UBI, monthly tickets for public transportation aren't that expensive, and you can certainly limit it to the residents of the town where it's implemented. > If you give a nudge that changes the behavior of many people, you can reach states that individual incentives can't reach. Sure, but you don't even know if people want that "nudge". I'm quite happy riding my bike, for example, which this would punish me for by raising my taxes which I have to pay on top of bike repairs etc. > Those same questions related to issues of what government should do and not to do. "Provide free & ubiquitous public transportation" is quite far along on the "nothing <=> everything" axis on what should be provided/decided/enforced by the government, I'm not so sure that there's a majority that agrees in most countries.