4 ms·
> You still want to maintain the markets. Giving every resident free card to use in public transport does that. Why not give them money instead? They can choos
by luckylion 8y ago
> You still want to maintain the markets. Giving every resident free card to use in public transport does that.
Why not give them money instead? They can choose to buy a ticket or choose to ride a bike/walk and use the money elsewhere. You might keep the market for public transportation (though I have my doubts: why would the provider need to respond to demand if he's paid no matter what?), but you're strongly intervening in the transportation market in general.
- OskarS 8y agoWhy does one preclude the other? "Free public transport" and "give poor people money" can both be excellent policies, there's no reason one should only pick one. The point with specifically making public transport free is because using public transport instead of using cars is A Good Thing. It's like a reverse pigouvian tax: we want to encourage people using public transport, so lets make it free. Instead of charging for it, tax something we don't like (i.e. cars) and pay for it that way.
- luckylion 8y agoWe're not just making cars relatively worse, but also walking and cycling, and we're encouraging (medium distance) travel in general. I don't know that this is a good idea, though I do agree that if you want to encourage travelling, it's fair to not only make it available to the rich. I'd much prefer people to use any form of transportation when required and not spend their leisure time by descending upon the inner city, but that's a personal preference.
- nabla9 8y agoTwo reasons. 1. UBI can be politically impossible. 2. You want to give incentive that is not local (individual level the best use of money) and becomes beneficial only when it applies to everyone. One individual does not generate enough inertia to change bus service, it's mass transit. If you give a nudge that changes the behavior of many people, you can reach states that individual incentives can't reach. There are sub-fields of economy that study reasons why markets don't solve all issues. For example the "Theory of company." Why we have companies made of large number of people where internal structures and incentive structures are shielded from markets forces? Those same questions related to issues of what government should do and not to do.
- luckylion 8y agoIt wouldn't need to be UBI, monthly tickets for public transportation aren't that expensive, and you can certainly limit it to the residents of the town where it's implemented. > If you give a nudge that changes the behavior of many people, you can reach states that individual incentives can't reach. Sure, but you don't even know if people want that "nudge". I'm quite happy riding my bike, for example, which this would punish me for by raising my taxes which I have to pay on top of bike repairs etc. > Those same questions related to issues of what government should do and not to do. "Provide free & ubiquitous public transportation" is quite far along on the "nothing <=> everything" axis on what should be provided/decided/enforced by the government, I'm not so sure that there's a majority that agrees in most countries.
- anoncake 8y agoGiving money costs money. Letting people use a bus that was running anyway does not. > you're strongly intervening in the transportation market in general. Good. Markets are not suitable for organizing transportation, this kind of thing needs to be planned.
- luckylion 8y ago> Giving money costs money. Letting people use a bus that was running anyway does not. That bus isn't running anyway though. It's (at least partially) paid for by ticket sales, you'll have to offset that by increasing the government subsidies to 100%, which costs money.
- anoncake 8y ago> That bus isn't running anyway though. Did Estonia have no public transportation before it was made free?
- luckylion 8y agoThey probably did, but before it was made free implies that somebody paid for it. If those people no longer pay for it and the state picks up the bill, the state needs to spend more money. Unless the employees of the transportation providers no work for less money, of course.
- anoncake 8y agoTo the extent people previously paid for tickets, free public transportation does cost money of course. But that is not really a disadvantage: The people of Estonia gains just as much by not having to pay for tickets individually as they lose by paying for them collectively by way of their state. If the increased ridership necessitates an increase in capacity, that clearly does have a cost. But often, a route has much higher capacity than necessary in order to increase frequency or to keep the schedule more regular. No one should decide against using public transportation in such a case in order to save money. Making it free prevents that. Paying money to people is also effectively free for the state to the extent that they use it to purchase tickets for spare capacity of public transportation or other things the state provides that have zero marginal cost. But people almost certainly spend a smaller share of that on spare capacity than if they receive it as "tickets". So free public transport may not be free, but it is cheaper than paying people the money their tickets would have cost.