3 ms·
This article sounds really good at a high level, but it misses an important point. Prior to the invention of the radio, lower level commanders always had to us
by nl 16y ago
This article sounds really good at a high level, but it misses an important point.
Prior to the invention of the radio, lower level commanders always had to use their initiative when commanding their troops, because there was no reliable way to quickly communicate with their commanders during a battle.
It's disappointing this was missed, because it's an important point: Control needs to be proportional to communication.
Also:
They also were taught to live off the land by hunting and foraging. This decoupled the soldiers from the slow supply caravans and allowed them to remain independent for long periods of time.
The author probably should have pointed out that this tactic led to his armies in the Iberian peninsular being bled by attacks form the local population sick of having the crops stolen by "foraging" soldiers. It also led to the Russian disaster - the Russians left nothing for the French armies to forage, and so when winter came they ~all died.
- bsergean 16y ago100.000 out of 600.000 survived, and a lot of them were not french but from many places. They did not all died of starvation, many were killed fighting cossacks.
- hacker-gene 16y ago> Control needs to be proportional to communication. First time I've heard of this, and I'm pretty sure there's good insight here somewhere (I don't think I've heard it mentioned anywhere), would be great if you can expand on it.
- nl 16y agoThanks. I just made it up.. but I don't think it's anything complicated. Control should only be exerted over things where you have sufficient knowledge. In a rapidly changing environment - be it business or battle - knowledge can only come via communication. Strong centralized control can only work well in environments where communication is strong too. Otherwise decisions must be made with less knowledge than other parts of the organisation closer to the action the decision affects.
- davidw 16y ago> Thanks. I just made it up.. but I don't think it's anything complicated. It's a nice phrase and concept. If you could fluff it up a few hundred pages, you could get a business book of your own out of it...
- plastics 16y agoThat control and communication are correlated is one of reasons why feudalism became so 'popular' after the fall of the Roman empire.