4 ms·
Silly me. Yes, totally mistook title 25 for 5, while it was buzzing in my head. Once again, I'm reminded why we have lawyers, and why google is not a proper leg
by baybal2 8y ago
Silly me. Yes, totally mistook title 25 for 5, while it was buzzing in my head. Once again, I'm reminded why we have lawyers, and why google is not a proper legal search engine. Yet, the point that most of official offences are not a matter of title 18 (criminal code) stands
I give you +1 for a good, substantiated argument
But still, US has very lax stance on official responsibility, and very fundamentally on the idea of whether a failure to perform duty in office or required specific performances pass as an offence for an official.
> Making poor job performance a crime, for someone with no mens rea, is inherently totalitarian and abusive.
Does US has a stance on failure in official duty being mens rea defensible? A number of Western democratic state don't think so. I'm not meaning for something like an ordinary clerk failing to show at work being a case of it, but for government officers with highest levels of responsibility — positions onto which people certainly don't get by simple promotion.
- torstenvl 8y ago> Silly me. Yes, totally mistook title 25 for 5 Your citation was not to "title 25," either. This was not a numerical mistake. You cited the regulatory code, rather than the statutory code. They are entirely different bodies of law. > the point that most of the official offences are not a matter of title 18 (criminal code) stands Yes. Another point that still stands is that you fundamentally misunderstand how important it is not to over-criminalize behavior of this type. The surest sign that a regime is corrupt is that it imprisons those it claims are corrupt. See, e.g., https://www.scmp.com/news/china/article/1679489/xi-jinping-vows-press-chinas-war-graft https://www.scmp.com/news/china/article/1679489/xi-jinping-v...
- baybal2 8y ago> Your citation was not to "title 25," either. This was not a numerical mistake. You cited the regulatory code, rather than the statutory code. They are entirely different bodies of law. Well yes, I will not be a lawyer. After all finally remembered, ch 11 of title 18 (criminal code) is what was buzzing in my head at the time. Somehow "abuse of office" felt like it belonged there. I concede on that, IANAL defence does not work when you engage in a dispute with a lawyer with encyclopedic knowledge of the code, and you totally embarrass yourself :) > Yes. Another point that still stands is that you fundamentally misunderstand how important it is not to over-criminalize behavior of this type. And you cite China as an example, out of all countries... Lets follow this logic: a single stroke of a pen by a senior government officer of a big country can easily cause enough damage (economic, property, life, moral) for it to be comparable to a war loss. Just let the guy go? Last time I checked, generals loosing wars were usually relieved of heads, not jobs (even in USA, during the revolutionary era.) The senior-most official positions must be coming with responsibility other than something like "suspension of no more than 14 days," and this is what a lot of nations subscribe to, and not all of them are communist satrapies. In big part of Western Europe and former UK colonies Misfeasance in public office is at least a matter of an administrative liability with a lot of actionable laws against it.